MovieChat Forums > Homecoming (1996) Discussion > Did you like this movie?

Did you like this movie?


i really enjoyed this movie. What about you

reply

Just saw it today, and I loved it. I haven't read the book in five years, and it's made me want to pick it up again.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]


yes i loved the movie also, its a shame they dont bring it out on dvd.

reply

There is a link on the movie's detail page (upper right corner) to DVDs for sale on the Internet (in this case, Amazon). Following this DVD link, I discovered it is a rare DVD and hard to find. The two copies that are presently available (at this writing) sell for $129.90. So, you <I>can</I> get this movie on DVD. It is just unlikely you will find a copy or will have to have money to burn (or be very, very motivated) to spend that kind of money for the DVD.

reply

Spend fifty bucks and buy and ALL-ZONE dvd player. Then you can buy this dvd at Amazon's United Kingdom site for about ten bucks and you'll be able to play this dvd (any dvd from any zone in the world). Worked great for me, and now about half my films are from foreign countries.

reply

Yes, I liked it. Very well cast, I pictured those characters exactly as they were cast.

reply

Yeah, but I knew Bancroft's grandmom was a softie from day one.
Dee4j

reply


I saw some of the parts and it looks like a good movie. I hope it will be on again real soon.

Lester A. Vineyard

reply

Yes, I do love the movie. Its actually one of my favorite. I guess they already have it on dvd. Check amazon.com or bn.com for info.

reply

From what I saw of it, yes, I did like it. I hope they show it again on t.v. so I can see the whole movie.

reply

It's gonna be on the Hallmark channel this week or next early in the morning. Check the T.V. guid. You can also rent it at Blockbuster.

reply

[deleted]

Yes I did like it! But one thing I noticed that was in the book but wasn't in the movie was when they met those people on the beach....Other then that it was good.

reply

The movie glossed over a lot.

They did not only leave out the people they met at the beach. They left out the people from the circus. There were the boys who took them across the inlet I think.
I think there were a few more.




If you don't have much to begin with, then you don't have much to lose.

reply

Yes, I liked it a lot.

Tomorrow's just your future yesterday!

reply

I think it is a fine movie. It could easily be sappy with lost kids finding a home. But the gritty characters- grandmother and the siblings- really make it a cut above. Anne Bancroft as the reclusive grandmother and Kimberlee Petersen as the 13 year- OLD "mother" of the children are especially good. And Hanna Hall is adorable as the shy and sensitive Maybeth. A very well told story.

Get the DVD.

Blaine in Seattle

reply

Eh. It's OK. Anne Bancroft slumming, but then, there aren't many roles for an actress of that age.

reply

While the movie wasn't all I hoped for and the surrounding cast might not have been uniformly stellar, I'd hardly say it was slumming, especially when it's such great material from Voigt's novel. There are number of Oscar winning/nominated or well-respected actresses who have been turning to TV films or series in the last several years. Most of them have said they do it because the roles for women are better written or they are given more of a chance to be the lead or do more than in film, especially for middle aged or older actresses.

Come, we must press against the tide of naughtiness. Mind your step.

reply

I liked it, but a lot of the good essential parts of the book are missing here. I know there are time constraints, but I still think it could have included a couple more parts.
The casting ranged from excellent (Sammy was perfect, James was good as was the grandmother. Maybeth was very good too). But Kimberlee Peterson was a bit too "stiff" as Dicey. Her words were pronounced too clipped and a little woodenly.
Bonnie Bedelia was awful as Cousin Eunice, she seemed 'fake' and was not the best choice.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

I agree with you on some.


I saw the movie first then just read the book.
I actually thought that she was perfect for Dicey, she was awkward as Dicey was.
Some of the movie sentences that I thought came out stiff were actually written like that.

I am like you though, I disliked BB as the cousin. I do think that the actors playing Sammy, James and Maybeth were the best.


If you don't have much to begin with, then you don't have much to lose.

reply

Excellent movie. I have two major categories of movies - "would watch again" and "would not watch again." This is in the first one for me - a classic movie. I thought the actress who played Dicey did a great job. Sometimes a person who has been hurt and has to handle responsibility beyond their years might sound wooden or clipped - it's the bracing of oneself against possible adversity, it's the summoning of one's strength.

reply

Wow, I just noticed this thread was started 10 years ago.

I really like this movie, and I think you'd have to be pretty hard-hearted to not be a little bit taken by it. The children (especially the three older children) give good performances, but this movie really comes alive with Anne Bancroft. She turns in a fascinating, deep performance that rises way above the level of the usual TV movie.

Although the writing deserves some credit, it's really Bancroft's performance that keeps this character from being perceived as hateful, crazy, or unlikable. She makes the character interesting, funny, and beautiful in her way. We see from the very beginning that there's something else going on beneath the surface, that she longs for familial connection and must be hurting beneath her harsh exterior. I love the way she begins to appreciate each child differently, for his or her own character strengths, all character traits that she relates to in some way: Maybeth's quiet dignity, James's intelligence, Sammy's wilfulness, and Dicey's protective maternal instincts.

I really like the lingering message of this movie, too: that your actions are much more important than your words or gestures. The grandmother is harsh and angry with words, but her nurturing and caring come through with her actions from the very beginning. She pushes Dicey and the kids to stay; she feeds them and makes them feel useful; she gives the younger boy a bicycle and cares for Maybeth's arm while encouraging her to come out of her shell a little. You can't help but like this woman. And that independent, fighting spirit is of course something in the grandmother that the kids can relate to, something that makes them different from that "simpering" cousin Eunice.

The photogenic setting also helps this film. It's fun to watch these neglected kids enjoying life on the farm.

reply

I am with you on Anne Bancroft, she was an amazing and talented lady. I do have to say that if you read the books she played the part perfectly so that she could get across that even in her fiesty/angry moments you know she cares but she is scared.

I wanted to read the books after seeing this movie, so far I read Homecoming, Dicey's Song and a A Solitary Blue. I am very impressed. I have Sons From Afar and Seventeen Against the Dealer.

If you don't have much to begin with, then you don't have much to lose.

reply


Excellent post,aaslatten. I agree.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

[deleted]