MovieChat Forums > The Crucible (1996) Discussion > OT: Why Majority Young Girls and Women?

OT: Why Majority Young Girls and Women?


Was it never asked why the accusers were all girls and why the accused were majority women?

Why was it not like the Crucible and a jealous girl accused a boy she was smitten with, or accused the girl he really loved?

reply

Well, you have to remember the time period. In this time, women were judged by all to be the weaker sex. Woman was the one to first listen to the temptation in the Garden of Eden. Therefore, women were more likely to fall from God's grace again and serve Satan. And since men controlled everything in the society, especially the courts, it was far easier to convince them that a woman was consorting with the devil than that a man was doing so.

reply

But it's still strange, men were 'in charge' yet again, like taking the apple, they so quickly decided the girls were telling the truth and began attacking these innocent people.

No one decided give the girls more chores to do to keep them busy, or something like that.

reply

The majority were women, at least the ones in the courtroom throwing fits while the accused were on trial.

There were older women and men who were accusers, though men were less likely to go into fits, partly because of gender mores. Tituba's husband, John Indian, frequently had public fits, but his status pretty much demanded that he had to in order for people not to accuse him. Goody Putnam also had fits.

Abigail was not the only instigator in the real trials. The Putnam family played a much bigger part in making accusations. As for the jealous girl part, that never happened. Arthur Miller made it up for his own personal reasons. Poetic license. (Laughing about John Proctor being called a "boy," when he was actually quite elderly.)

Men had their evil roles in this too. Reverend Parris, Mr. Putnam, and Judge Hathorn and the others that presided over this miscarriage of justice.

reply

I know it's an old thread, but I wanted to point out that the writer Nathaniel Hawthorne is the grandson of John Hathorn, the judge. One theory behind him changing the spelling of his name was to distance himself from the judge. Clearly, the Salem witch trials weighed heavily on Hawthorne's mind, since three of his best-known works (Young Goodman Brown, The Minister's Black Veil, and The Scarlet Letter) use Salem as a backdrop.

reply

It's actually been brought up by some critics how Arthur Miller took a female story and turned it into a man's story. Rebecca Nurse, Mary Eastey and Ruth Putnam were very interesting women. Even 11 year old Abigail Williams was fascinating, as to this day nobody knows why she did what she did. Miller forced the entire thing into a common fictional narrative stereotype - the hussy, the married man, and the wife. No way the original Abigail (age 11) had sex with 60 year old John Proctor. If she had had, does anybody believe she'd have fallen "in love" with him? It's funny how Miller acknowledges raising Abigail's age, but does not acknowledge lowering John Proctor's. The real John Proctor seems to have been an outspoken man who bashed the accusing girls in public, was publicly skeptical, and that's why he was accused. Abigail accused not just his wife, but HIM of being a witch, and others besides. There is no sign she focused mostly on the Proctors. The original story was very interesting, but more complex and human than the play, which, face it, attracts fans not because of the parallel to McCarthyism, but because it's a fatal attraction story dressed up in high minded commentary about society. THAT is what endures. The triangle.

reply

I'm amazed I asked this on a Crucible page, as I've never really watched any version of The Crucible. I think I asked this around a time I was checking into versions of the Salem trials in other movies.

What I managed to look up on The Crucible, I found to be absurd with it's 'spurned woman' theory. That would be like retelling 9-11 as a jealous suitor or something.

Thankfully, so many versions of the Salem Witch Trials I saw did not quite follow this route. One of the best was Three Sovereigns for Sarah, with Vanessa Redgrave.

reply

Same reason why young girls today follow these stupid trends - they are sheep, incapable of independent or logical thought. Look at all the trouble they caused both back then and even today.

Women must be told what to do at all times. Let them run amok like this and see what horrors hapepn.

Wendy? Darling? Light, of my life!

reply

I'm not going to disagree with this.

reply