MovieChat Forums > The Crucible (1996) Discussion > Scenes that are akward to read in front ...

Scenes that are akward to read in front of a class...


I'm a junior in high school and my English class just finished reading this. We're watching the movie now. When going through the parts for the play I volunteered for Abigail Williams. I had no clue what I was up for. All I knew was she was one of the main characters, and about my age.
The scene with John Proctor is extremely weird to read among your peers. Especially telling one of my fellow class mates that he "sweats like a stallion."

Sorry, haha, this might be a little OT but I thought it was sort of humorous.

"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply

We're reading it now in my honors english class. We only acted out one scene, and it was the same scene between Abby and Proctor. It was awkward to do, but really funny to watch because the lines and actions in the play for the two playing those roles were so out of character for them. We couldn't go more then 10 seconds without laughing, and teased them for days.

With its heartache
With sorrow
Winter wind sings and it cries.

reply

lol that's funny. I'm reading it in class as well and i was Abigail...

i started laughing and my teacher told me to "grow up"...but hey, it was funny to me.

reply

Are you guys acting it out or just reading and discussing? Unfortunately, my class went back to option #2 (we only acted it out in the first place to get out of a test; my teacher forgot to give us the vocab words until the day before the test). I wish we'd go back to acting. I did better on the test after the show, and started doing poorly after we went back to the reading (my teacher's tests for this play are all quotes of all things!).

With its heartache
With sorrow
Winter wind sings and it cries.

reply

So far, we've only finished ACT 1.
We had it read to us from a tape over a matter of two days, and then we had to answer questions, fill in a character web, take notes on the describing parts between the dialogue and we're told to not read ahead.
What ever happened to reading a book from page 1 to the end?
Why do we have to analyze everything?
Do any adults seriously sit down with a pen and paper and take notes to remember points of a good book?
If this is a good book (which it is so far), why would you have to take notes to remember stuff?
This is stupid.
Yes, I'm bitter.
And I'm a Junior in High School.

reply

Right on! I wonder the same things when we read a book in great detail for school. I mean, I know doing all this gives us good reading skils and whatnot, but does it really matter if Hale IS OR IS NOT sympathetic (actual question in the Critical Thinking in my txbk)? Or the IRONY of Goody Nurse being accused? And WHAT WAS THE MATTER with Betty anyway?? I hate how things like this are never explained, even though it's part of what started the whole witchcraft hysteria in the play.
I miss the simple days of grade school reading.
Yes, I'm bitter too.
And I'm a sophomore in high school.

With its heartache
With sorrow
Winter wind sings and it cries.

reply

I hate havin' to analyze everything...I usually read ahead if I can...they do that b/c of Standardized testing, on which they stress us too much.

Just how close can I get Lord to my surrender without losing all control.

reply

melissa76017, i laughed also and my teacher said the same thing

<3

reply

We performed this play in my High School just yesterday. I was Rebecca Nurse. Oh wow, was that a weighted role. People think it would be so easy to play her, yet coming across showing all of her character is rather difficult. You need to make her old, but strong. You need to make her sad to hang, but strong enough to deny confessing to witchcraft. You need to make her religious, but not accusatory. She had a lot of hard pieces to pull together.
But, back on topic, my friend (a very churchy girl) played Abigail Williams. Holy cow was that fun to watch!! It was definately out of character for her, but she is such an amazing actress... it was just amazing how she pulled that off!

Ye may not survive to pass this way again. And these be the last friendly words ye'll hear!

reply

Talk about awkward - We just finished reading it in my honors class and had to act out scenes between Abby and Proctor. By the way, I go to an all girls school. Super awkward.

reply

I love going all out. everyone sucks and doesnt get into their character but I go crazy and totally act the part out. it makes things fun. your not you, your a character. dont read too much into the role.

reply

The really awkward thing is when your male teacher reads that scene.

If we clone people soon they'll want to be called "Replicated Americans"

reply

We're reading it and we have very few guys in my English class. Every guy in the class had a part so one of the girls had to read John Proctor for that scene. The girl who played Abigail felt pretty uncomfortable because of the "sweating like a stallion" part. Sadly we just read and discussed.

RIP Dimebag Darrell 1966-2004

reply

My Junior Lit class read this about a year after our school performed it. I was one of the big drama type guys in my class and my teacher was one of the directors when the show was performed. I was picked to read the part of Proctor and out of the entire class, NO ONE volunteered to read the part of Abby. Given the unwillingness of any of the girls in class, my teacher read and acted out the part of Abby. TALK ABOUT WEIRD!!! The only good thing about this was that the other girls in my class volunteer to read in the female roles opposite myself for the rest of the year. Good stuff.

reply

my sophomore lit class is reading it right now, and we're still immature at some parts of the play hahaa even the teacher laughs too. =] it was akward reading the relatioship part of abigail and proctor.

reply

Haha, in my class my English teacher read the part of Proctor and this girl had to read the part of Abigail when they're talking about their affair... it's awkward enough between two teenagers; imagine reading those lines with your teacher. xD
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You alone can make my song take flight...

reply

I totally know what you mean. I also volunteered for her part b/c none of the other girls like to read a lot aloud. Yea, I read ahead and gasped and all the kids looked at me and then turned to the page and started laughing. We read that scene the next day and I thought I was going to die. The worst part was that Proctor was being played by one of my best guy friends.....WEIRD!!

reply

Haha same here. Doing it for my Higher Drama class and I was Abigail.

The best though was when our teacher was noting down quotes from memory to describe Proctor and Abigail's relashionship, only she misquoted Abigail's line "I forgot how strong you are, John," as "I forgot how hard you are, John" ROFL

She'll never here the end of it! Bwahahaha!

Yeah 'The Crucible' is the best.

reply

[deleted]

hey erin i was just wondering if you go to riverview like i do.

"If I have to hear "Yamo Be There" one more time."

reply

WHORE!!!! WHORE!!!!

reply

[deleted]

I'm reading it in my class... I'm John Proctor, lol

-Izzy

You Snooze you lose

"Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate, Hate leads to suffering." -Yoda

reply

Nope, I don't go to Riverview.
We left The Cruicible behind a few weeks ago, but my friends and I still like to revisit it. I go up to my friend who played John Proctor and get really close to him and throw out something like "I'd forgotten how strong you are, John Proctor *wink*"
So, let me reiterate a bit about my experience. We're sitting there in English class and my teacher is asking for volunteers. I didn't know what I was up for, looking through the characters and for some reason Abigail Williams stood out to me. I volunteered for it. My good teacher, always looking out for me, doesn't give me any warning. He simply looks at me, looks at the character list, looks at me, looks at the character list and says "Hmm. That's kind of an interesting role." Okay. I like interesting roles. We didn't get far that day but the next day I got a nice warning from my friend who has English before me telling me about the "smut" we were reading. Fortunately I had some warning, so I was sitting there, reading ahead the whole time until we finally arrived at the "upstairs" scene. I stifled a laugh as I read in a voice that was way too serious, "Gah. I'd forgotten how strong you are, John Proctor." I giggled. I was handling it rather well until the part about the stallion, when I completely lost it. My teacher was really good about it and didn't throw me out or anything.
There was none of that teacher as John Proctor business in our class. I probably wouldn't have been able to handle that, or forget about it. Ever. "Yeah, you put the knowledge in my heart, and I'm not talking about literature." Akwardness. My teacher read a little bit as Parris or somebody. He got way into it more than anyone else, it was great.
The best part in our whole Crucible unit was when we took a test on the first couple of acts. One question was "What are some disputes between the various characters?" I wrote down a few lame ones and then I wrote in these words "Well, Elizabeth Proctor was probably mad because Abigail was shagging her husband."
My teacher got a nice laugh out of that.
I'm going to tell my teacher that I'm starting an online support group called UJGVaAW (Unfortunate Junior Girls Volunteering as Abigail Williams). Any takers? XD


"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply

sure, i'll join UJGVaAW, erin!

im at an all girl's school (in England), and we're doing this play in drama. boy is it weird doing the proctor and abby scenes! the other day we workshopped one as a class (the one near the beginning - in the attic in the play, behind the house in the film) and the pair had to keep going over it, and the girl playing abby was told to 'be more seductive and get much much closer to proctor'

but that's just me.

reply

Hahaha...that sounds incredibly awkward...reminds of a similar experience...I performed the Crucible earlier this year (I was Abigail (b/c I'm a BAMF!haha)) and I always had to go to "private" rehearsals with the guy playing Proctor...it was basically our director saying really bizarre things (especially when we were rehearsing the woods scene" like "Jess, you want to make mad passionate love to Robbie, okay?" or "I want it to look like you two are having sex on stage" ...yeah, uh, AWKWARD...

reply

lol! what's a BAMF??? (anything like a MILF???)

but that's just me.

reply

Haha yeah, my honors american lit class is reading the "stallion" scene..

well, we were the other day

our teacher called it "Puritan Porn"

and... well, no one could stop laughing so we BARELY got through the scene

lol

reply

Puritan Porn? lol! that's awesome. Nobody in our class said anything like that, but at that same part right after I said the "stallion" bit this kid next to me is like "Oooh, I'd like to see that." sickos, haha.

"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply

Just a point of clarification, when Abigail says she remembers Proctor, "sweating like a stallion" this is not a direct reference to their actual affair (although I suppose this could be implied). The entire sentence is, "I know how you clutched my back behind your house and sweated like a stallion whenever I come near!" (Act One, ln something or other). The "clutching the back" part is racy, but the "sweating like a stallion" part just means that he gets really nervous around her. I can imagine he would, especially if his wife is around as well.

reply

Well yeah, that is true. It still sounds weird though.

"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply


Just finished reading it. (junior in high school).

there were several awkward scenes. I for one think Arthur Miller did it on purpose, the crazy bastard.

reply

Very recently we had to act out a scene from the ending of the third act. I played Abigail and I had to be called a whore. The guy playing John had to point right at me and say "It is a whore!" That was probably the most awkward part of the whole thing haha

reply

[deleted]

Haha, that's awesome. Good plan.
The other day I told one of my sophomore buds that she should volunteer for Abigail Williams next year when they get to The Crucible. I was like, "just do it, don't even think about it." And she's like "okay I will!"

Then I felt bad. So I got my text book out and let her read the smutty part.

"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply

there are very few people in my english class that like to read so the same people would read it everyday...some people would get two or three parts so sometimes it turned out they would be talking to theirselves...it was really funny actually

reply

So I presume from all these posts 'The Crucible' appears alot on the American syllabus for English literature? Which year/grade does it appear - I am in year/grade 12 and had never heard of this but I bought the DVD cheap today just because Winona and Daniel were in it. I liked it and thought it would be good to study - we mainly do stuff like Shakespeare.

"When I light a candle at midnight I say to the darkness I beg to differ"-Sr. Helen Prejean

reply

I did one of John's monologue for my acting final in College. In order to practice, I needed to find a place to dampen out the sound (as the scene is quite loud at parts). I took it upon myself to practice while taking a shower. Little did I know that the poor girls upstairs could here me plaintively sob "God help me, I lusted!" in the shower.

reply

lol poor you

"When I light a candle at midnight I say to the darkness I beg to differ"-Sr. Helen Prejean

reply

"Which year/grade does it appear?"

I think the Shakespear stuff in grade 12 is normal. I did the Crucible Junior year, as I think others on this thread said they did.

"Gentlemen, I wash my hands of this weirdness..."

reply

[deleted]