Would 'Cobra 11' work in North America?


Youtube has given me a taste of the German TV show "Cobra 11" despite the fact I live in Canada. Despite the intense action sequences, on the Western Hemisphere of this planet the show seems to be unheard of. I've heard someone describe it as the German version of the American show "Fastlane" (Despite the fact Cobra 11 pre-dates Fastlane by quite a few years and unlike Fastlane, is still in production).

I wonder if any TV execs from the U.S. (or Canada) have seen this show and wondered if it would work. I hear it's a hit in Germany but differences in taste may hamper its sucess in North America if it were to be imported to this side of the globe. First thing I noticed is after seeing the over-the-top action sequences (What I like the show for) I questioned how much effort was put into things like plot and storyline. True to my prediction, reviews on IMDB that have seen the show claim that those things are poorly implemented at best. Unfortunately, for a lot of people plot and storyline are much more important than crazy special effects and a few people (who are Canadians like me) I have shown Cobra 11 footage to have said it's too far and even stupid.

Being a foreign language show, I wonder if that would pose problems. Unlike other countries, very few foreign shows get imported here (North America) and I wonder if the show could be sucessfully dubbed over into English while preserving lip-syncing, or sub-titled. There has been a history of U.S. networks showing interest in a foreign show but instead of bringing it over create their own version of the show locally (Such as how there is an American version of "The Office".

That being said, how do you think Cobra 11 would fare on American/Canadian soil?

reply

I think Cobra 11 is better described as "'LA Heat' with plausible plots (and screenplays)" :) Stunts are also spectacular but not so exaggerated like in most US shows.
Though I think the key of the European success of Cobra 11 is charachter development and relationship, which are "human", aren't just "fun & comradeship"
I think it's better than ANY similar show produced worldwide, including the US.
It would meet success in North America, but I don't think that's going to happen, just for the reason you mention.

reply

I actually liked "L.A. Heat". Wish I had taped it back when it was on years ago. :(

reply

No I don't think it would work here at all, as the original show is too ridiculous for people here in the US and too violent to be on regular TV here as well.

reply

Too violent?! In the Country where "CSI" or "Law & Order" are followed by 20 million people...?
I'm really surprised, Cobra 11 in Italy is currently shown daily at 19:00 and last year even on 17:00, it's simply "PG" suggested, while NCIS, Without a Trace, Cold Case (just to mention American TV shows broadcast by the same Italian TV channel) are "suggested for adults only".
I actually think Cobra 11 is less violent than Miami Vice.

reply

I think it would work..

BMWs, Mercedes, Porsche police cars and German Autobahns, those are pretty cool things for most americans ;-)

reply

You never saw the Lamborghini used by Italian Police :)
But I'm glad they didn't crash one of them, till now!

reply

I got hooked on this show when I was in Germany, and it probably appeals to car nuts. Remember that CHiPs had poor plotlines, but we tuned in because we wanted to see cars totalled. And the stunts are amazing.

I think of this as CHiPs but the guys are in cars and not in uniforms! When my friends ask me, I always say, ‘CHiPs meets Lethal Weapon.’

Fastlane was too stylish for its own good with its rock-video inspirations, though I can see some similarities (two cops, cars, female boss).

Dubbed shows have not done well traditionally in English-language markets. However, I have watched the dubbing they do in Italy, and the Italians do a really good job. As English has more similarities to German, I think it would not be too bad.

One other issue is that the show has run for so long and the back-stories would make less sense for new viewers. Does one start showing 1996 episodes which are woefully out of date (and the pace is also off by 2000s’ standards)? Starting now, viewers would have to accept Semir is married and Andrea is expecting, while long-time viewers saw the courtship; we would also need to understand that André, Tom and Chris have been killed in action, which probably drives Semir to be more serious.

This show could go one of two ways in North America. It’ll either be rejected for being too foreign, or it’ll gain a cult following through car nuts (and there are a lot of us). Things like time slot will have a lot to do with that; promotion will, too. Non-American shows have tended one way or the other, and no one has really been able to predict which way things will go.

Jack Yan
www.jackyan.com

reply

When I saw previews of this show on Youtube, my first thought was that this was a German version of CHIPS.

reply

I used to live in Italy and watched the dubbed (Italian) version aka "Squadra Speciale Cobra 11" and the car crashes (usually started with it) was over the top. It might not work in the US or UK though



My Voting history is secret;)

reply

It is running in the US now at least in Chicago, but dubbed in Spanish. As far as getting an audience here, there are probably enough chase 'n' crash highlight edits on YouTube to satisfy most folks...

reply