Another Unmovie


So since when should movies have a plot? A start, a finish and an end. Like "It's A Wonderful Life"? "Safe" was very boring. If it's about anything, it's about schizophrenia or depression. Hollywood and the film makers of the world aren't going to be confined to creating something everyone should like and understand. "Safe" is one of these movies. The viewer should accept the movie as it "grabs" them. It's funny how actors are virtual slaves to the whims of the writer-producer.

reply

Oh yes let's fall into the trap of Hollywood where everything is wrapped up neatly with a little pink bow at the end. Don't worry there is the Marvel Comic Film Franchise making billions of dollars catering to your ilk.

reply

I agree and disagree with both of you. This movie was NOT a stereotypical Hollywood product! In fact, it goes very much against the Hollywood formula.

I do agree however, that this movie is a labor to watch and unless you want the meaning of a movie to be of your construction, you shouldn't enjoy it. In fact, getting out of a movie, what you want, pretty much betrays the reason for watching movies to begin with. We watch movies to follow a story and be entertained, not to have an incomplete story handed to us to finish in our minds.

I see Stupid People...

reply

"We watch movies to follow a story and be entertained..."

We likely have very different definitions of what may constitute a story. A formulaic plot-line may relieve the audience of the need to think very hard, but this does not necessarily make for a satisfying movie. To be actively engaged can be of far greater value than to simply be entertained.

Safe is a film that challenges us to contemplate shallow materialism and charlatanism. Moore's character had everything society taught her to value in terms of comfort and privilege. It is no wonder that her dissatisfaction left her in an increasingly precarious state of mind. Unable to discern the nature of her troubles, she decides the source comes from outer toxicity. The flyer at the gym asks, "Do You Smell Fumes?" This suggestion triggers her flight to commune to be "cured."

The film is thought-provoking and makes demands of the audience that few films dare approach. This may well render it an "unmovie" for some, but I found it quite compelling. The ambiguity works for me, and is the sign of a filmmaker who trusts the audience with the challenging material. Seeing it again, newly remastered by Criterion, reminded me why it stuck with me for so very long.

Highly recommended.

reply

We watch movies to follow a story and be entertained

Funny...that's just what this film did for me. It also stimulated me to think for myself. I guess that's a bad thing, eh?




Religion is like a rocking chair -- a lot of work to get nowhere.

reply

I had recently seen a reference to this film in Entertainment Weekly and heard good things about Julianne Moore – who I think is a fabulous actress. I managed to locate a rare copy on eBay. Just watched it Saturday with two friends; one had seen it before, two of us hadn’t. The first-time viewer said he would never watch it again.

Myself? I was glad I saw it but felt inclined to immediately put it back on eBay to recoup my $29 cost. So I came here to see what everyone’s thoughts were and it sounds as if I should give it a re-watch. I just thought the second half of the movie moved quite slow. As a sucker for a happy ending, I was hoping Carol would good some relief. So, I felt as if I was left hanging. Will give it another viewing and see if I feel differently.


Twitter - Allowing you to publicly put your foot in your mouth since 2006.

reply