The last two notes


Listen to the last two notes of the "American Symphony"--a high, triumphant note, in octaves, featuring strings and brass (and probably the rest of the orchestra), followed by a low, sustained major chord which dies slowly (a "diminuendo", to you).

Now get to your CD or "record player" and put on "A Day in the Life" by the Beatles. Listen to the last two notes of that song--a high, triumphant note, featuring strings and brass, then a low, sustained major chord which dies very slowly. (I don't mean the spliced, looped bit at the end, just the song itself).

Now consider the similarities and the fact that Holland was supposed to be a Beatles fan in the movie. The endings are so similar that it warrants at least some consideration. Either:

1) Michael Kamen (the composer) deliberately put a Beatles motif into the American Symphony to suggest that Holland, the character, had been influenced by the Beatles in his composition (which would be perfectly plausible);

2) Kamen himself unwittingly and/or subconsciously took a "bit" from the Beatles. This is quite plausible, too, and is perfectly forgivable.

Kamen died well before his time in 2003, so we can't ask him.

Just another of those minor things that keep a person up at night.

(Editing in: I put the last 5 seconds of MHO and the last 5 seconds of "A Day in the Life", end-to-end, using Garageband, with a 3 second gap between the songs, played it to my class of 16-year-olds (who had just seen MHO) and they were amazed at the similarities in the endings.)

reply

This is in the trivia section here on IMDB.com for this film:

Near the film's conclusion the piecemeal orchestra, made up of former students of Mr Holland, plays his long awaited composition. As Mr Holland demonstrates throughout the film, he is a great admirer of John Lennon, so it is only fitting that the very last note played in his piece of music is exactly the same struck piano chord heard in the Beatles, "A Day in the Life" (although The Beatles chord is an E Major while the Mr. Holland chord appears to be an F Major).

reply

Oh, ok. Didn't realise that. (I rarely look at the trivia sections).
The last note in MHO is not actually a piano chord, but a sustained chord by the orchestra.
Thanks again.

reply

If you insist on regurgitating the trivia section, I'll continue to call BS.

Perhaps the OP just wants to reach out for some sense of community.

reply

They left out the bit about superman though...

reply