Smoking


What irked me most was the smoking! Most of the main characters smoked frequently, and that distracted me from the telling of the story. If the smoking had some function in the development of a character, or in the movement of the plot, I wouldn't object. Few people still smoke in the economic and social bracket of the characters in "American Quilt," and those who do, especially in California, are forever going through apologetic behavior about it. It's possible the student (Winona Ryder) might have been a smoker, since some students smoke as a kind of death-defying statement.

reply

Uh different time frame these women came from. Stop applying todays values to then.

reply

[deleted]

The smoking irked you most? Not the woman who cheated on her dying true love with her sister's husband? Not the horrible deterioration of Sophia's life dream? Not the emotional prison of an artist's wife who can't bear to stay and can't bear to leave? Not Finn cheating on her perfect fiancee with a male floozy?

Nope, definitely the smoking.

"Two little mice fell in a bucket of cream..."

reply

Lol 

People love to harp on the smallest of things.

Very good. But brick not hit back!

reply

reminds me of the rob reiner anti-smoking episode of south park!

Larry Gaylord: "a billion people come in on a day off, and they don't flip out!"

reply