MovieChat Forums > Yin shi nan nu (1994) Discussion > The Father and Her Fiance.

The Father and Her Fiance.


Why did the father go for the woman's daughter instead of her? Why did she agree to marry him? She is too young for him.

reply

i believe he married her cos she offered him something new that had previously ben missing from his life.

i think that if he went with the mother, then he would be repeating the repitition or mundanity of his life.

i think she agreed to marry him for similar reasons, they found something in each other that they felt they had been missing. he was kind, charming, and delightful to her daughter, so it doesnt seem like a stretch for her to like him.

cheers

reply

It's rather obvious from watching the film that Jin Rong's mother is obnoxious and uncaring, and also very obvious that Mr. Chu finds her to be as annoying as his daughters do. Why would you expect him to marry such a woman? Just because they are of a similar age?

It's a shame that people put so many restrictions on love today.

Jin-Rong and Mr. Chu fell in love. They are both mature, caring and lonely people with love to give and looking for that right somone to help give them what they need to get their life back on track. They have alot in common: they both feel isolated from their families, they both have raised children on their own, and they both wish to love and be happy again. They are a near perfect match regardless of their ages. They fell in love. It's really that simple. I thought it was very sweet and worked very well and if anything, for me, the age difference showed how much they must have really loved each other.

reply

The mother would drive a saint out of their mind. She made no rational sense -- one minute, everyone should be married -- a minute later, marriage never works out.

She's an airhead. A bimbo. If she'd ever heard any voice not her own it would be a revelation of "biblical" proportions to learn of it.

And in one scene she's putting her cigarettes out in the food he'd made.

As for the age difference? How great is that, at most? 20-25 years?

reply

My husband and I just finished watching this movie. We're Asian and 10+ age differences in marriage is not uncommon in our culture. We also understand the relationship, affection, and connection of Jin-Rong and Mr. Chu. Our main concern is that realistically, women live longer than men. If we're being extremely generous, Mr. Chu may have about 20 years of life left in him, but highly unlikely. Jin-Rong will be a widow for a long time. I'm not sure about the Chinese culture, but in our culture, widows are often ostracized and not respected. Their chances of getting married after their husband dies to someone who truly loves them is also slim to none...especially with two kids.

Again, I don't know about the Chinese culture. Jin-Rong has some hard years ahead of her without Mr. Chu especially if they continue having kids. It's not a good situation for her in the long run, but she'll have a few blissful years with him.

The Truth is Out There

reply



**********
In Stranger Eons

reply

I Agree 100%

reply

In the first scene of the movie the father is actually talking to Jin-Rong on the phone about breaking the news of their relationship to his family. He later tries to bring it up by saying, "For the last two days.." but is continuously interrupted. This is why Jin-Rong stops at his house later that evening, but unfortunately he is helping at the restaurant.

reply

Oh wow didn't see that! This makes it fall into place.

reply