MovieChat Forums > Vanya on 42nd Street (1994) Discussion > Other Commnets on 'Vanya on 42nd'

Other Commnets on 'Vanya on 42nd'


One of things I noticed with a second viewing of "Vanya on 42nd" was very faint sound of police siren from outside the theater. It's strange to hear it because on the one hand, it's an accidental anachronism, like the I<3NY coffee cup, and yet OTOH, that achronism, while tangible is so distant to our perception.

I think my favorite actor was Brooke Smith simply because her portrayal of Sonya moved me the most. That's saying a lot because I'm usually not moved by scenes of heartbreak and suffering in movies. Not saying I'm cold, but that Smith really conveyed pathos. For my money, much could be written about Vanya, Sonya, and the Doctor imprisoned with stoic realism sandwiched between his hedonism and idealism. Watching "Vanya on 42nd" just made me think of life as I know it, people as I know them and interact with them. I mean it's, dare I say, very "moral" in a way.

reply

[deleted]

Agreed--Brooke Smith's performance was lovely, so understated and moving, and really they all were perfect. I felt that Julianne Moore's performance at times was hard to take because of her excessive laughing or crying, but likely that was how she manifested her character's superficiality and troubledeness.

reply