MovieChat Forums > U.F.O. (1993) Discussion > Middle Class Snobbery

Middle Class Snobbery


I am getting fed up with middle classes assuming that they know what is "proper" comedy. These are the sort of people who howled over "Burn After Reading", a woefully unfunny, and god awful, film that should never have been financed.

Roy "Chubby" Brown's comedy derives from his working class upbringing and the pubs and clubs he used to perform in. As a working class lad myself I find everything he says hysterically funny. Why? Because that's the way we talk. We do spew forth expletives at every given opportunity. We do tell sexist jokes. It's just the way we talk. The working class don't work in offices. We work in factories and warehouses. The older generation worked down the pit. "Chubby" Brown is somebody that we can identify with. Go to one of the old fashioned pubs in a mining village and they still have "turns" on on a Saturday night after the bingo. They're not wine bars where everybody drinks fancy spirits. Proper pubs where people have there own seat and they all know each other. A real community.

All the negativity thrown at the likes of Bernard Manning and "Chubby" Brown nearly always come from London's middle classer's with no idea of real life outside the capital. They seem to think that anybody who doesn't live in London lacks intelligence. But they do laugh at other "middle classer's" like Michael Macintyre or Jimmy Carr.

In short it's nothing more than middle class snobbery.

reply

In a way a fair point as Roy Chubby Brown is very funny, but is never going to receive any awards for it; however this film is not very funny.

reply

[deleted]

I don't find 'Chubby Brown' funny at all, infact I find his material rather vulgar.

But your ridiculous claim that 'racism' is one of the reason he is becoming less and less popular is totally unfounded. Look at the most popular comedys around today for teenage-young adult audiences: Family Guy, for example, who continually pokes fun using the stereotyping of Jews and foreigners as 'punch lines'. If you wan't a more blatant look at Racism in a popular cartoon look no further than South Park - which I assure you addresses more intelligent issues than most of the rubbish comedians come up with today. Both of these are hugely successful in the modern era.

For stand-up look at Chris Rock, he consistently pokes fun at the 'white man' stereotypes. Or Al Murray who mocks staunch 'Nationalism' as the basis of his comedy.

Focusing on different races, cultures or ideals is far from dead in Comedy, no matter how much those who want everything to be 'rainbows and candyfloss' wish it was.

Oh and for the record, I'd probably be referred to as middle class, and I somewhat agree with the OP that Chubby relates more to the working class. Thats probably why I'm not a fan.

reply

USARooLS -

Cock off, Nobhead! Don't talk bollocks! What's you being middle class got to do with TRYING to kick the crap out of me? Pillock! And what's with the name? If you're English why have you put "USARooLS"? If you're American than this thread doesn't really apply to you. I'm not a troll. I was trying to show the difference in humour between classes. The other posters got it.

reply

Piss off! Roy Chubby Brown isn't funny because he just isn't funny. And this class crap is nonsense - my mum and dad come from a council estate, and most of my family are on the taxis, or worked down the pit. My uncle was the guy that sold the discounted towels at Ingoldmells Market. The fact that, through hard work and intelligence, my parents made it to the middle class does not deny me the right to say that Chubby Brown is dated now, was dated in 1993, and has never been funny. Bernard Manning was about 10 times funnier than Brown, due to timing and mannerisms.

reply

What the *beep* are you on about? If you don't find him funny then fine. I was having a go at the snobs not at people who just don't find him funny in general. And at what point did anyone try to deny you the right to your opinion? How is Chubby Brown dated but not Manning?

reply

I'm working class and I've worked in offices, and being snobbish about people with discerning taste in humour is still being snobbish. And Roy Chubby Brown is still crass and unfunny, as is anyone who makes the same pathetic jokes he does.

reply