MovieChat Forums > Lassie (1994) Discussion > Was this collie debarked?

Was this collie debarked?


It seemed as if "her" voice was very quiet compared to the ringing bark of other collies that I've heard. I've heard debarked dogs before and "her" voice seemed similar.

reply

What's debarked mean?

If Practice Makes Perfect and Nobody's Perfect,Why Practice?

reply

When a dog is "debarked" it has had surgery performed on its vocal cords to make its bark sound softer. It's a relatively common procedure used on Shetland Sheepdogs and some toy dogs, especially those who live in areas with noise ordinances. I've just never heard a collie bark so quietly before! LOL

reply

Oh. I love the way Lassie barks. It's tight. My colliedoesn't bark like that. It's more of an annoying high pitched bark.


If Practice Makes Perfect and Nobody's Perfect,Why Practice?

reply

[deleted]

I don't think so. I have two collies - one is very high pitched and squealy when she's excited (playing, doorbells, etc), gruff and quiet when she's "speaking" on command. My other one is almost silent, but has a soft "wuff" that means "something's up" and a big, bad, rarely used "roorooroo" for threatening circumstances.
Lassie is also a really big dog, and larger dogs tend to have deeper voices.

reply

This Lassie is not debarked. His bark is very similar to most collies today. If you went to a Collie show, they would all sound very much like this dog. They have a wide range of sounds, and can be very vocal. I noticed in the older black and white shows, they usually have Lassie barking frantically when something is wrong. And they do bark like that when something really is going on. It's that almost ear pearcing bark that everyone is referring to. It seems they trained him to use the more tone downed sound they normally have. Not so much of a bark, but more like just an almost conversational woofing. This one sounds almost identical to my oldest Collie, Scarlett. Most people say my dogs sounded exactly alike when they were all together, but I've always been able to tell them apart of course. but if i closed my eyes, I'd swear it was Scarlett barking.
My youngest collie, Grace, came to me already debarked. The debarked sound is much quieter, usually a whisper. A lot of show breeders debark their dogs, and believe me, it can be tempting! But I prefer to hear them. Their barks are part of their personality and what makes them individuals.
And now I've revealed what a dork I am by analyzing the Collie bark.

reply

LOL Sorry to take so long to respond to you, but no, you are not a dork! I know which one of my four Toy Fox Terriers is barking at any given time by pitch and tone. If I weren't supposed to be workig, I could probably analyze each and every one in detail. :)

reply

Okay, so I'm a dork too, but I've had five collies, and I can always tell when a collie is barking. They have a distinctive "sound" and are very vocal. I believe that vocalizing is part of their herding style.

My dog also has what I call his "big collie" bark and can be quite threatening when he's in protective mode. Collies are great dogs!

reply

I have two blue merle collies, brother and sister. Mac the brother has a very low, male bark. But Shadow's bark is much higher. Collies have different barks as the people above said. I know when it is a protective bark, a "I have to go out" bark and a "I'm mad and just want to be irritating" bark! At least their barks are lower than my samoyed, Cirrus. For a big male dog, he has a high pitched bark!

reply

We had my collie debarked and her voice doesn't sound like a bark anymore, but more of a hoarse coughing noise.

reply

One of our collies had been debarked by the breeder when we got her, and she sounds similar to Lassie.

*EDIT* The poster above me perfectly described her "de-bark".

Blood is the rose of mysterious union...

reply

In my opinion, that is cruel.

I live in a glass house, ergo, I throw no stones.

reply

Yeah, it's pretty sh!tty.

__
Are Chinese Americans even real Americans? - ROU_Killing_Time /smh

reply