Angel Heart


I've been a big fan of Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers since it came out in 1993. I even read the novelization that Jane Jensen wrote. It's such a great story mixing sleuthing, voodoo and New Orleans.

I had never seen the 1987 Alan Parker film "Angel Heart" until today. It stars Mickey Rourke as a private eye in 50s New York sent down to New Orleans by a myserious client (Robert DeNiro) to locate a missing man. The story involves voodoo, a young voodoo priestess (Lisa Bonet) whom the Rourke character gets involved with, and murders in New Orleans. Rourke's character Harry Angel looks & acts very much like Gabriel Knight. He even has an attractive assistant who does his research like Grace. And Lisa Bonet's character is almost identical to Malia Gedde. The one problem is that Angel Heart came first. I wonder if Jane Jensen saw it and was inspired to create GK.

I've noticed that in other Sierra games too.
In particular, Police Quest: Open Season, which borrows its villain & its ending from that of "The Silence of the Lambs."

What do other people think?

reply

Well, if you want to look at what sort of influences she had, try this one:

Sins of the Fathers involved magic.
The Beast Within involved werewolves.
Blood of the Sacred, Blood of the Damned involved vampires.
The fourth game, had it been made, was rumored to involve ghosts.

White Wolf Game Studio's first four RPG games were Vampire, Werewolf, Mage, and Wraith.

It's probably just coincidence, though (regardless of what White Wolf seemed to think when suing Sony over the Underworld movies) - the myths themselves have been around for ages, and it doesn't take THAT much effort to decide to use them. The key is using those ideas to write an effective story, which Jensen did in these games...

reply

I just saw 'Angel Heart' the other night (great, great film, by the way), and I'd have to disagree with you about the similarity between the film and 'GK1'; with the exception of it being a mystery involving New Orleans Voodoo, it bared very little resemblance.

First off, while Mickey Rourke's Harry Angel character does look like Gabriel Knight, I find their personalities to be vastly different. Angel is a tough, hard-boiled detective who can be rather aggressive and threatening when he's trying to squeeze information from people, while Gabriel Knight is much more laid back and gets by on his charm and charisma. You can feel sympathy towards the character of Gabriel, but not so much Angel.
As far as Lisa Bonet's Epiphany Proudfoot character goes, she does LOOK identical to Malia Gedde, but differs in personality. Malia is a sultry, mysterious socialite and Epiphany is a much younger, seemingly more vulnerable girl living in poverty. She doesn't seem to reflect any sort of dark or ominous tones, at least not to the extent Malia does. Although the relationship between Angel and Proudfoot does remind me a bit of the relationship between Gabriel and Malia.
As far as the attractive assistant who helps Harry Angel out, nearly every old-fashioned P.I. has one of those. However, unlike Grace, the woman in 'Angel Heart' is featured only briefly and isn't that heavily involved with the story.

And, of course, the plots are completely different: In 'Sins of the Fathers', Gabriel investigates into a series of murders caused by Voodoo people of which Gabriel soon gets involved into, where as, in 'Angel Heart', Harry Angel is hired on a missing persons case which leads him to New Orleans and the case eventually involves a secret voodoo society. Of course, that's just the bare bones descriptions of the two, as both of them have deeper plots, but they're still totally different.

And, um...I guess that's all I have to say.

reply

It still seems Jane Jensen was at least inspired by some scenes from the movie : the tap dancing black boy or the heart ripped from the chest of a body scene. The lover of the hero is also a voodoo preistess in both cases, and the said hero witnesses a voodoo ceremony - the alternate ending of Gabriel Knight could be a reference to Angel Heart's. The fear of chicken of Harry Angel and the threat through chicken body parts are also somehow mirrored in Gabriel Knight. Of course, all of this could reflect an athmosphere of both New Orleans and voodoo (fantasized?) rituals rather than be a real plagiarism of the movie.

reply

Yeah, I saw angel heart for the first time yesterday and came here to open a thread just like this one.

I liked the first hour of angel heart - I thought the twist was cleverly done, but wasnt really for me.

I loved the mood of it though, made me feel the same way I did when I played SOTF for the first time when i was about 12. I also liked jensen's novelisation of the game, despite it feeling a bit like a walkthrough.

I'm going to play the game through again now.

Oh, and Malia Gedde is way hotter than Epiphany Proudfoot

reply

Yes, but Malia Gedde wasn't nude like Lisa Bonet...

reply