Yeah, that's the Paul Lee Johnson book on the McLaury's. I still want to read it, but I've heard so much about how it's more of a biography of Will rather than Tom and Frank, that even though it's well researched, it's hasn't been a priority to me.
To respond to your question/thoughts. I definitely think that Stillwell, along with Pete Spence were the two worst (from what we know, of course). But yeah, Stillwell was a piece of work, and so was Spence. I didn't see them so much as cow-boys as much as criminal opportunists. Generally bad people who got off on being bad and getting away with stuff. I may be off-base, but that's my general view of them as people.
Curly Bill to me reminds of the dialogue in Pulp Fiction, talking about pigs being filthy animals and therefore not eating them:
"Do you consider a dog a filthy animal?
"I don't eat dog either."
"But do you consider it a filthy animal?"
"Hmm, a dogs definitely dirty...but a dog's got personality. Personality goes a long way."
"So by that rational, if a pig had a better personality, it would cease to be a filthy animal."
"That would have to be one charming pig!"
Curly Bill, to me is like the charming pig. He's a bad guy, but not so terrible that his good personality and (perceived) generally pleasant disposition can't make your forget about it. I think he was more dangerous than people think, but not dangerous in the classic gunfighter sense.
Likewise with Ringo. I think he was very dangerous in some ways, but not as a legendary gun-hand. I think that Ringo probably did have something about him (more than just a cool name) that made people regard him, but being unable to put a finger on it, he got the classic treatment of embellishment. I agree that he was a loner in a sense, but I also think that he was very much a part of the cowboy contingent. In short terms I think he was independent, while at the same time, dependent on the cow-boy culture and life in SE Arizona at the time. If that makes sense.
He doesn't strike me as someone who would ever try to challenge Curly Bill for a leadership role, or even pursue it, but at the same time, probably relished having those around him revere him. I think he was probably manic depressive, and very eccentric. This would make him a very curious character, and much more than a one-dimensional cow-boy just simply getting by. I think that sort of character aroused interest in the rest of the "gang", as well as the early writers.
I definitely don't think he was dangerous in the street-fight shoot em up sense, and he's probably lucky that Doc and Wyatt and didn't accept his challenge in the street. Of course there's also the theory that there was someone backing him up in an upstairs window with a rifle. But that's the kind of dangerous I think he was; underhanded and self-serving. But definitely a character, just not the one that's been painted.
Overall, I think that Curly and Ringo were not the biggest threats in the group when it came to being "bad-men" or gun play. And Stillwell and Spence were, I think, the lowest of the association.
"I am on intimate terms with the desert..."
reply
share