MovieChat Forums > Tombstone (1993) Discussion > Has anybody ever read...

Has anybody ever read...


...Wyatt Earp, a novel based on the Kevin Costner film? It was written by Dan Gordon, who with Lawrence Kasdan wrote the story for the film.

It's interesting only because I'm reading everything I can find about Wyatt, Tombstone, and it's various characters.

But this novel plays with the facts far more than the film. Referring to Allie Earp, "She was a large woman."

They make Mike Gray of the town lot controversy into a leading bad guy, dealing with Old Man Clanton, and deciding who can and can not be killed. They also give him one son, Dixie Lee, completely ignoring John Pleasant Gray.

Prior to the state robbery where Bud Philpott was killed, they have Doc announcing that he's heading for Contention. In real life, he was headed for Charleston.

They have someone insulting Big Nose Kate because of her nose. She wasn't called that because of her nose, she earned her nickname because she always stuck her nose in other people's business.

They have Josie and Wyatt hooking up far earlier than they did in real life. They also make Wyatt a U.S. Marshall way too soon, instead of after the attempt on Virgil's life.

There are some humorous scenes, such as when China Mary intimidates Mike Gray into calling off attacks against the Chinese, but overall it's nothing but a piece of fiction. I will finish it, but I'd probably only give it two stars.

Anybody else read it? What did you think?


I intend to live forever.
So far, so good.

reply

I enjoyed it, sort of. Apparently it was based on the treatment or script of the original project, which I believe was going to be a miniseries, with Mike Gray as a kind of Tombstone Godfather, to whom even Old Man Clanton pays allegiance. One problem I have with it is that Wyatt is kind of passive, constantly being duped and out-generalled by Gray (who even arranges the Battle of the Plaza in Dodge City as a means of getting Bat Masterson out of Tombstone!). In real life Wyatt was undoubtedly a naïf when it came to politics but in the novelization he just sort of gets pushed around from pillar to post until the guns go off.

As I recall in the novelization, Gray kills himself after his son is killed with Old Man Clanton; but the real life Gray didn't. I liked the part with China Mary although it seemed to be filler to flesh out the miniseries.

By the way, re China Mary, not too long ago I watched an episode of the Wyatt Earp tv series with Hugh O'Brian as Wyatt, and there was one episode in which Wyatt investigates some murders in "Hop Town," Tombstone's Chinese quarter. China Mary is played by the famous silent movie star Anna May Wong. I was hoping Shotgun Gibbs, Wyatt's fictional deputy in the series, would say: "Forget about it, Wyatt. It's Hop Town."

reply

Read "The Last Gunfight" by Jeff Guinn. You'll like it.

reply