MovieChat Forums > The Piano (1994) Discussion > What a beautiful film. Too bad I dislike...

What a beautiful film. Too bad I disliked the female protaganist


Because she was a two-timing, backstabbing, hussy! I think I would have liked the film more if I liked her.

Anyways, why was she mute? I can't recall.

reply

Of all the posters I have seen on this site you have to be one of the worst. In a lot of your posts you go on about this person being immoral, and that person being immoral, stripping is immoral, the movie Happiness is immoral etc etc. You should change your name to jcjudges cause that is exactly what you are. You are the reason that Christians are seen as being pompous, self righteous, holier-than-thou twats.

Why would you watch movies that you obviously know will have sex,stripping, violence, paedophilia, and then criticise it saying it is immoral??? If you had any sense you would switch off the film as soon as YOUR standards are being compromised. My personal belief is that you have not seen any of these films that you judge to be immoral, but read a few things and make a judgement based on what you hear and read and not what you see. You never respond to posts that you start up, which in my book means that you are a troll seeking attention. Maybe you shouldn't change your name actually, it would be more ironic if you kept it, as you are the person that jc needs to redeem!!!

P.S. Your post on West Side Story romanticising pre-marital sex and not letting your children watching it was the funniest thing I have ever read. Now go and pray for forgiveness.



Fitter, happier, more productive

reply

WOW, invest in some Xanax! I can't believe you managed to use Christian and twat in the same sentence. If I did not find it so *beep* hilarious, I may have been offended.

reply

Actually, Bravo! to GavfromCt..b/c he's right. Also 2 cool pts for the Radiohead signature.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

And some non-Christians can't spell. Hooked on Phonics, motherf----r!!

reply

[deleted]

Ohhh okay, you must have one of those nonexistent computers that does not emit light.

reply

[deleted]

amen gavfromct. Can't stand self-righteous bastards. Obviously you didn't get the point of the story but no it's, "how dare she fall in love with another man, and not like the unappealing, loveless arranged marriage she was in. She's a sinner!" lol. It's just a movie, you ass. Just see it as a beautiful, very unconventional love story and stop trying cast stones at your idea of Mary Magdelene here.

Predictions:DiCaprio/Streep/Winslet/Fiennes

reply