MovieChat Forums > Naked (1994) Discussion > My interpretation of Johnny (spoilers)

My interpretation of Johnny (spoilers)


Some of the stuff I'm about to write is not original but I feel the need to express my thoughts en toto on this film.

Johnny is the ultimate nihlist. He's bent on self destruction during the peiod in which this film takes place for reasons that are not specifically clear but I don't think specifics matter. Somebody said it's becasue his mother sexually abused him but, even if that's the case, it's incidental.

I think one of the most important moments in the film is when Johhny denies that he is bored. This is obviously a lie. He's way smarter, at least intellectually, than every other character in the film. The only way that he can be entertained by people around him is to indulge his dark side to the fullest and just totally screw with everybody he comes across. His screwing is merciless and extreme, indicitave of extreme boredom.

He abuses Louise by denying her the one thing she wants which is to connect with him. He never really answers any of her questions throughout the whole film. He abuses Sophie by making her fall in love with him and we know where that goes. He abuses Brian in two ways. One by finding out what makes Brian sleep well at night (the whole future/destiny thing) and intellectually ripping that to pieces and the second by disrupting the fantasy that Brian has about the woman across the way. His abuse of the woman across the way is interesting because it's mainly to mess with Brian but, while he's at it, he might as well pull her hair steal her favorite book. She's in too much of a drunken stupor to be a really entertaining target anyway. He abuses The Cafe girl by illustrating how dull she is and then adds insult to injury by guit tripping her when she reacts to it (I think there's more here but I don't see it yet). He abuses the sign poster by just generally disrupting the guy's very apparent focus in doing his job. He abuses Sandra just by messing with her uptightness but eh seems to emphathize with her exsaperation.

I find it interesting that the only characters he does not abuse are the Scottish couple. I think this is because they are so tragic on thier own that he just wants to spectate at thier insanity. They're the only characters he shows curiousity in. He seems very disappointed when they just run off at the end of that sequence.

His encounter with Jeremy is not quite clear to me. It's the only character he tries to legitmately bond with. I'm guessing it has to do with him recognizing the pure evil in Jeremy and his natural attaction to the prochecy of self destruction. Jeremy seems to embody the emotional darkness inside him that he is actualizing throughout the film.

Another detail that I think is important is that he hints that he is very ill in some way. He says something to Brian about it but I couldn't quite figure out what he said. That combined with his apocalypse beliefs, I beleive, are the impotus for his self destructive ways.

Thanks, if you read all that.


reply

[deleted]

Hi, I must say that is a pretty good interpretation of Johnny. I think he will go down in cinematic history as one of the most complicated characters in British, Social-realism cinema. I agree that he is bent on self destruction, but I don't agree with the fact that he is bored. He never actually says that he is bored with life and that he hates himself for what he has become.

I believe that the only reason why he abuses people is because of their own self-loathing. Sophie hates herself because of her lack of intelligence. The woman in the window, Brian, the cafe girl and the sign poster all hate the way their lives have turned out. Brian hates himself because his wife has run away and he has a boring job. The cafe girl, the woman in the window, sign poster don't care that they have nothing to live for. It's this self loathing and self-abuse of life that brings out the worst in Johnny. Johnny has an A-Level in psychology, so presumably he believes that if he hurts the people who hate themselves they would go away and start a better life. Sophie runs away after being hurt by Johnny, but what happens to her we will never find out. Unfortunately this psychology is interpreted by the women in completely the wrong way. I reckon if he had met Jeremy at a different time and in a different frame of mind, the two would agree to Johnny's theories. Except Johnny doesn't mean to be hurtful Jeremy does.

All in all I don't think there will ever be a complete analysis of Johnny, he a bit like Hamlet, he will react differently to different people. It just comes down to the absolute genius of David Thewlis and Mike Leigh, and I doubt even they can directly say what's wrong with Johnny.

I hope this is the start of an exciting argument.

David Thewlis fan for life.
E.Constable

reply

Great analyses. I agree with them to quite a large degree.

reply

[deleted]


I think one of the most important moments in the film is when Johhny denies that he is bored. This is obviously a lie. He's way smarter, at least intellectually, than every other character in the film. The only way that he can be entertained by people around him is to indulge his dark side to the fullest and just totally screw with everybody he comes across. His screwing is merciless and extreme, indicitave of extreme boredom.

That's not how I see him.

I think he is genuinely interested in the people he meets.

Like a child, he has a short attention span. I suppose it could be said that he tires of people (ie gets bored of) people easily. But overall he is not bored. As quickly as he tires of one person, he can run off to someone new.

eg he's having a nice chat (in the warm) with the security guard. But then he sees someone through a window, and wants to know her story.

Or else he (and only he) shows any interest in Sandra's trip to Zimbabwe. No sooner is Louise gone, than he is trying to find out all about being a nurse.

Sometimes people disappoint him (eg the window woman) and he tires of them more quickly than others (eg Louise), but I dont think he is (yet) bored. However, Brian's warning (which he will not heed) is likely to be a prescient one. One day in the future, Johnny will realise that he's bored. He'll realise that he no longer gets the same buzz out of meeting new people that he once did. That's when he may begin to suspect that he may have wasted his life.

reply

"I believe that the only reason why he abuses people is because of their own self-loathing. Sophie hates herself because of her lack of intelligence. The woman in the window, Brian, the cafe girl and the sign poster all hate the way their lives have turned out. Brian hates himself because his wife has run away and he has a boring job. The cafe girl, the woman in the window, sign poster don't care that they have nothing to live for. It's this self loathing and self-abuse of life that brings out the worst in Johnny. Johnny has an A-Level in psychology, so presumably he believes that if he hurts the people who hate themselves they would go away and start a better life. Sophie runs away after being hurt by Johnny, but what happens to her we will never find out. Unfortunately this psychology is interpreted by the women in completely the wrong way. I reckon if he had met Jeremy at a different time and in a different frame of mind, the two would agree to Johnny's theories. Except Johnny doesn't mean to be hurtful Jeremy does.
All in all I don't think there will ever be a complete analysis of Johnny, he a bit like Hamlet, he will react differently to different people."

That's one of the best analyses of Johnny I've ever read!

Allow me to add something. I also believe he will lose respect for a woman if she jumps in bed with him right away, hence why he's so mean to Sophie after they have sex, and hence why he really isn't mean to the cafe girl until she kicks him out.

-Amanda

"She will remember your heart when men are fairy tales in storybooks written by rabbits"

reply

Very true. I think Johnny truly enjoys the odd people that he meets, but at the same time, I think that on some level, he dispises them. This is due to his condescending natureand mind games. Not that he really means to be this way. It's just what ends up happening.

I think it's good to point out that Brain's question is the only question in which he doesn't have an answer for (sarcastic or serious).

reply