Férula Trueba was lesbian???


I didnt understand it,,, was she?

reply

[deleted]

I don't think she was necessarily a lesbian, I think she was just so starved for human contact that when she got it from Clara she couldn't get enough. She has the saddest life, and is abused by her mother and brother to the point that she forgets she is alive. Her years living with Clara and Estaban are the happiest she ever is.

reply

That's how I interpreted it too. Clara was the first person who wholly embraced her with love, expecting nothing in return.

"I wanna go to Hogwarts"
- Two A-Holes At A Travel Agency, SNL

reply

I think she felt something very special (in an homosexual way) with Clara.

reply

I don't think so but I think her brother does

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, in the book he threw her out wearing just her nightgown. But she scared the s**t out of him (and the rest of the family) when she came by on her way to heaven to say goodbye to Clara. That scene was really creepy.

reply

yea, that scene in the book gave me chills. creepiest scene in there, and some weird *beep* goes down in that book.

and i don't know about the movie, but i thought that in the book ferula rode a fine line between maternal love for clara and a kind of obsessive love that almost made it seem like she want to be clara's mate; ex., when she would make excuses in order to sleep in bed with clara. the line was definitely blurred, but i think for the most part she just loved clara deeply and wanted to be loved - in whatever for that love would take - by the one person in her life who never asked anything of her.

reply

Thanks for your answers!

reply

To me, Ferula hadn't "matured" sexually or emotionally as she was still a virgin and didn't know how to distiguish sexual desire from affection.

reply

Yeah, this was a really tough thing for me to interpret, too, but I think the first person who responded to this post (v_basketmom) hit it right on the nail. Ferula was such an emotionally neglected person, so starving for human contact, and when Clara gave her that unconditional love, she couldn't get enough. It was all she ever wanted, and all of a sudden, she had it. I think it's mostly up to the audience and each person's own interpretations, but although it would be easy to think that there was something bigger going on between Ferula and Clara, I really don't think that was the case, now that I think of it.

It's a tribute to Glenn Close's acting in the scene where her brother is throwing her out, and she says, "For Clara's sake, I want you to know it was never the way you imagined it between us. Never." The way she said it, you can genuinely sense that she is telling the truth, and you can feel it in her voice that all she ever wanted was to be loved and wanted, and the years she spent with Clara and Blanca were the very best she could have possibly had.

But then again, the confession Ferula has with the priest tells another story. Maybe Ferula did have some kind of feelings for Clara deep down inside, but because she cared about her and never wanted to hurt her, she wouldn't dare come out with it. But really, when you consider the poor woman's life and how painfully lonely she was, it makes all the sense in the world that she just wanted a family to call her own. Having been without that human contact for so long, she probably couldn't distinguish between those two types of love and affection. And also, if you think about it, Clara was a hugely perceptive person, due to the "gift" she was born with to foreshadow things, and I think that if Ferula felt that way about her, Clara would have known it and sensed it. As Ferula said once in the movie, Clara was a sort of "angel," and her time on Earth was only a small piece of her. Clara had the rare privilege of seeing people for who they truly were, and she knew that Ferula was a friend and a sister that she'd treasure for the rest of her life.

That scene where Ferula's spirit comes into the house and kisses Clara on the cheek, then when Clara found her dead, always gives me the chills. Again, it's a credit to Glenn Close as an actress for making this character so deep and multi-dimensional.

reply

Yes, this is what I thought. When Esteban finds both of them asleep he goes crazy because he imagines something dirty in his dirty mind.
Férula was just a disgraced woman, and Clara gave her the first evidence of love she ever felt.
Who knows, maybe Férula would have tried something sexual, but simply because she would have overreacted to his relationship with Clara.

reply

I felt she was sexually repressed and could've gone either way.

reply

I don't think she was a lesbian. She was just really lonely.

reply

I think she was asexual as far as looking at Clara as a sexual being. She loved in the most powerful way that goes beyond sexuality and lust. She loved Clara in a spiritual way, she thought Clara was an reincarnated "Angel". She loved her for who she was and believe she represented something beyond just a human. When she did her confessions to the priest she basically in her own way worships Clara the same way a nun worships God.

reply