MovieChat Forums > The Fugitive (1993) Discussion > How does a doctor do better detective wo...

How does a doctor do better detective work than the police?


He actually looks into who would want to hurt him and his family. Maybe someone with a fake arm??? The police automatically think it's him. Why?
-Because he gets insurance money if his wife dies? Wow doesn't every husband?!
-Because she said his name during the 911 call? There could have been multiple reasons!!
-No forced entry? Ever think maybe the door was unlocked??

Give me a break!

I remember during questioning they say something about a gun and bullets that had Kimble's fingerprints on them?? Why would they??? Was his gun even used in the murder?

I love this movie but the fact that he has to do all this $*** to find out who killed his wife because the police are lazy at their *beep* jobs is head scratching.

reply

He was motivated and he had time. He wanted to bring justice over his wife's death, he wanted to save himself from false accusation and he KNEW the one-armed killer was real. This was life and death to him.

I think that once the police heard that 911 recording and her saying Richard's name at the worst time, as if she is declaring he is the attacker, that they thought they had their man and didn't need to waste anymore time or resources because they have 100's or 1000's of other cases to work on.

Deutschland hat die Weltmeisterschaft zum vierten Mal gewonnen! πŸ‡©πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

reply

Anyways back on topic....the 911 tape isn't conclusive proof, any competent defense lawyer would make mincemeat of it and his gun was indeed used to kill her...during the struggle she gets her hand on the gun and then there is more struggle during which she is shot with her own gun...now the killer probably had gloves on, so her prints should be on it and also Richard if he handled the gun somewhere later on.
Also to note the killer loses his prosthetic arm during the struggle with Richard after which he runs...how did the cops not find the arm!!
And after so much struggle, how the forensics not find absolutely any forensic evidence on a third man in the house, like his hair, skin traces in her nails (they only find Richard's from when he's holding her while she's dying).
Even the motive that he killed her for her money is pretty weak...he was already an accomplished doctor with no criminal record or mental history.

Basically OP is right, there is not much detective work on the police side (considering it's such a high profile case)...nor is there any conclusive evidence to warrant a death penalty by lethal injection.

The film just focuses a lot on the action.

-----
wat are you lookin' at...ξ‚ 

reply

The arm wasn't actually left at the crime scene, it stayed with Sykes. It became dislodged, kind of just dangling from his elbow but it was still on his person, in his possession. There was no arm left. Sykes took the arm with him when he left.


Deutschland hat die Weltmeisterschaft zum vierten Mal gewonnen! πŸ‡©πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

reply

The same way a retired school teacher in New England always solved murders that the bumbling police couldn't handle, I guess.

reply

Don't you mean Maine?

reply

Well, since the state of Maine is considered part of New England...

reply

Well, I know tons of school teachers from New England who fancy themselves amateur sleuths. However, only the one in Maine became famous enough to have her own tv show.

reply

I'm sure you're referencing some other show but let's assume some of us may not have watched whatever show you are talking about. What are you talking about?

Deutschland hat die Weltmeisterschaft zum vierten Mal gewonnen! πŸ‡©πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

reply

ck means "Murder, She Wrote" with Angela Lansbury. She plays a former teacher turned mystery writer who solves, you guessed it, mysteries. It was all quite silly.

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

Thanks, I'm aware of that show....I've heard of it and can picture the lady that played the lead but I've never watched it. I think my mom used to watch that.

Deutschland hat die Weltmeisterschaft zum vierten Mal gewonnen! πŸ‡©πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ

reply

Everybody's mom used to watch it. :)

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

lol you beat me to it. And didn't it seem like that small town had a pretty high murder rate?

reply

This is a decent (not great) popcorn movie but it's generally overrated in my opinion. Too many plot holes and ridiculous storylines. You raise some of the typical questions people on this board do. A surgeon is slready likely to be wealthy and so what his sife has money? That alone wasn't motive. He wasn't having an affair (nor was she) so one of the usual motives was ruled out. It's a fun way to spend two hours but the more you see it the more you see things that don't seem plausible...

reply

[deleted]

How does a doctor do better detective work than the police?


Easy--lazy screenwriters. One of the rules in lazy screenwriting is: when in doubt, always make law enforcement as dumb as a bunch of rocks.

---
Emojis=πŸ’© Emoticons=

reply

Sykes was a former cop.

It's fully possible that the Police deliberately were protecting him by putting it all on Kimble.

reply

I've always basically enjoyed the totality of this movie once I've gotten past the fact thst Kimble's original conviction seems ridiculous. He seems to have had a wonderful marriage and is well liked by everyone who knows him; why wouldn't he be believed about what happened? What motive was he supposed to have for brutally killing this beautiful woman?

reply

I've always basically enjoyed the totality of this movie once I've gotten past the fact thst Kimble's original conviction seems ridiculous. He seems to have had a wonderful marriage and is well liked by everyone who knows him; why wouldn't he be believed about what happened? What motive was he supposed to have for brutally killing this beautiful woman?

reply