MovieChat Forums > Fortress (1993) Discussion > Les Miserables vs Fortress

Les Miserables vs Fortress


Fortress seems to draw alot from Les Mis (the version I've seen is this one: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0077936/. I don't know how this compares to the original novel or other productions, but bare with me.)

Both heroes get a life-sentence (more-or-less) for a crime in their time which, by today's standards, is not a crime or justifiable in some way:
For Brennick, it's having a second child in a distopian near-future USA.
For Valjean, it's for stealing a loaf of bread to avoid starving to death in 19th century France.

Both villains (Poe / Javert) are villains not because they are diabolically evil, but because their situation puts them in opposition to the hero (namely managing the prisons). They themselves were sons of prisoners, who have seen little or nothing of the outside world. Despite being the villains, they are infact men of principle, it's just unfortunate for the heroes that these principles include absolute belief in the law, and that by breaking the law you forfeit all rights to be treated like a human being.

(I personally don't think of Poe or Javert as villains, but I couldn't think of a better word for the sake of this post.)

Any opinions?

Edited to correct some spelling.

--------------------------------------
I like posting in forums about movies.

reply

Add to this the prisoner numbers - in Les Mis I believe Javert keeps calling Jean Valjean by his number (24601) and he keeps responding with "My name is Jean Valjean", compare this with Fortress in the first meeting between Poe and Brennick and Poe tells Brennick in the form of his prison number to sit down to which Brennick replies "My name is Brennick". There are some definite similarities

reply

Thanks for contributing that goisthyname, nice to get some feedback! I'll have to look out for that next time I watch/read one or the other.

(... and the words I was looking for in my previous post were protagonist/antagonist rather than hero/villain...)

reply

Les Miserable is a classic, so it's likely to have influenced a whole bunch of stories later in time.

I agree with you Poe / Javert should not be called villains. A more appropriate term would be antagonists, as both oppose the protagonists. Normally the hero and the protagonist are the same character, (and soa r ethe villain and the antagonist) but there are exceptions as the present case illustrates.

reply