Please explain...


Can anyone explain and justify why/how the torturing of the small house pet was important? Current records indicate over 80% of people who abuse animals go on to commit violence against humans. Having crewed several films in various capacities (including animal wrangling) I know I would have strongly objected to the brutality of rendering the animal incapable of fight or flight; comparing the action similar to the acts of German government in the thirties and forties.

I hope someone can honestly address my concerns. Perhaps if I could understand, I would not feel that those who like and appreciate these scenes are all that different from those who would commit these acts.

reply

It started as his discovery towards the impact he could have on a life form, realizing he has this power to utilize.
This then lead to being put into force when he didnt like the manner in which he was being treated by his parents, and the fact his father had intruded on his place within the house (i.e - the relationship with his mother, which yes was perverse but still the life he had grown up to believe and experience)


reply

it's also important to note that children (and Bubby is basically a child) who are systematically abused by their parents or authority figures will go on to abuse animals or younger children whom they have power over. as well, Bubby hasn't learned any other way of treating someone. he doesn't know he's torturing the cat, so of course he doesn't know it's wrong. this falls more on Bubby's mother's shoulders than on Bubby's.

Bubby treats the kitten he finds later differently. he handles him gently. he calls him 'good cat'. he starts to speak to him in his mother's aggressive voice and then stops himself, and you can see a look of realization on his face that this is wrong. he goes to get pizza for the kitten in an attempt to provide for and take care of him. he is genuinely upset when the kitten is killed.

i feel the importance of the scenes is to indicate how Bubby is learning and growing and changing in the outside world. he is realizing that what he was taught and the way he was treated, and in turn the way he treated the cat, was wrong. and as for using animal abuse as a plot device, in a closed-off world like the one Bubby was raised in, i can't think of another equally-probable vehicle for Bubby to have displayed his power over. he would not have treated his mother in the same way he treated the cat, and there was no other living thing in the room.

i can only speak for myself, but i didn't appreciate the scenes because of the acts of animal cruelty displayed. i appreciated the scenes for what they said about Bubby and his growth into a loving, compassionate person who could develop the ability to care for someone.

reply

There was actually another living thing in the room. The cockroaches.... and Bubby pulled the legs off one and watched it wriggle around helplessly.

To me this was curiosity. The same as with the cat. He cling wrapped the cat to advance his knowledge of "not breathing". First he tried it on himself but he was unable to test it beyond what his mother had shown him. After he suffocates the cat he is somewhat disapointed that he can no longer interact with it.

reply

Bubby did went on to commit violence against humans. He killed at least 4 that we know of. The cat in the begining was crucial to display bubby not trusting his mother and experimenting with whether what she told him was true or not as well as replicating his mothers actions to others. The second cat was the moment when bubby understood what death actually is. Both of these cats were not just pointless shock addictions but actually critical for the plot, which makes them good additions.

reply

Untalented cruel idiot has money and makes movie, simple.

reply