MovieChat Forums > Ba wang bie ji (1993) Discussion > Question About Ending (Spoilers)

Question About Ending (Spoilers)


When Cheng Dieyi and and Duan Xiaolou were dragged outside and Xiaolou was dishing the dirt on Dieyi and his wife he seemed to find it hard to actually say what he believed the relationship between Dieyi and Master Yuan was.

He was utterly distraught when talking about it.

My question is; is this his disgust at the homosexuality OR was it jealousy as deep down he had romantic and sexual feelings for Dieyi?

Thanks for your thoughts.

-----

reply

It was the difficulty he had betraying his closest friend in the entire world. There was a very strong possibility Dieyi would be put to death as a result of these accusations, yet Xiaolou felt he had no alternative if he wanted to save his own life. Imagine being in that situation, having to choose between your life and that of the person you love most. You know that to save yourself, you have to admit every little thing the other person has done, and that in doing so, you are potentially signing that person's death warrant.

reply

Thanks very much for your post ComtessaLaRue, great point.

-----

reply

You summed it up quite nicely, ComtesssaLaRue. That scene has got to be the most powerful in the entire film for me because it showed the agony people were put through during the Cultural Revolution when forced to betray and denounce their closest loved ones in an attempt to save their own lives.

Even more haunting was the fact that Xiaolou had always been the King to Dieyi's concubine and unlike in the play, the King betrayed his loyal concubine to save himself. Leslie Cheung's acting was fantastic throughout and I loved his delivery when he stood up and pointed the finger back at Xiaolou and said, "Now even the King of Chu is on his knees begging for mercy!"

Such a powerful scene.






Namu Myoho Renge Kyo

reply

Thanks for your input. I agree, the scene was very heavy and powered with emotion.

-----

reply

the King betrayed his loyal concubine to save himself.

Great point about loyalty and betrayal, because so much of this movie is about deep loyalty between people, and you almost think that they could never betray each other. In the opera, not only is the concubine loyal, even the king's horse is! In real life the 2 men stick up for each other all the time, and Juxian is even loyal to rival Dieyi. It also seems to me that Dieyi is loyal to the whole notion of opera and doesn't want to see it compromised, though of course his relationship to art is more complex than that.

That lifetime of shared loyalty falls apart with Xiao Si's betrayal leading to the "outdoor trial" scene, which is painful to watch every time I see this film (4 times and counting).

reply