MovieChat Forums > Alive (1993) Discussion > Roberto Canessa new book

Roberto Canessa new book


Canessa recently came out with a book about his experience on the mountain. Has anybody read it?

reply

Thanks. Just put it on my Audible Wishlist and will buy it next pay.

reply

I've requested it from the library and should have it soon. I note that the co-author, Pablo Vierci, also wrote a book about the survivors that I am anxious to read, La sociedad de la nieve ("The Snow Society")which has, for reasons I can't fathom, never been translated into English. It contains first-person accounts from each of the sixteen survivors, plus much additional information from Vierci (extracts from these first-person accounts were used in the documentarty, Stranded)..

Here's the Google translate version of the Amazon.com blurb for the book:

This is the definitive book on the survivors of the Andes. The Greatest Story Ever Told. Each survivor testifies in first person and tells how the accident influenced their lives and how they live today. Interspersed with these chapters, Vierci recreates chillingly the most important moments in history: the airport exit of Montevideo, who did not travel for arriving late or being sick, accident, the wounded, the avalanche, the first expeditions in search help, group organization, death of coach rugby, death of family and friends whose bodies began to eat to survive, when they hear that presumed dead and no longer seek the finding tail aircraft rescue, the last expedition: a week of walking at 4,000 meters high and 20 degrees below zero, when they find the Chilean sheep carrier, the first questions of the Chilean press when rescued, back home.


http://www.amazon.com/Sociedad-nieve-Spanish-Pablo-Vierci/dp/0307392813

I have been waiting for it to be translated, but obviously this is not going to happen. I'm figuring I need to buy the Spanish edition, scan it, and run it through Google Translate or Babelfish, as it doesn't appear I will ever see an English translation, and it seems to be the most comprehensive overview of the events and the lives of the survivors since.

reply

I am listening to it now and so far it is very interesting.

I am surprised that Canessa says that Bobby Francois was his best friend. I don't think I have read that before.

Roberto's father also give his side of the story.

reply

I better order it. And I had no idea about the other book. It's a shame they don't translate it into English. Maybe someday...

reply

FYI Pedro Algorta also wrote a book that came out at the end of March 2016. The title is "Into the Mountains".

reply

Thanks for letting us know about Pedro's book. I have put it on my Wishlist and will buy it as soon as possible.

I am having two problems with Canessa's book. One is it non-linear nature but that might not bother other people. The second is that it is really a book that needs to be read after reading other books, I can't imagine what it would be like to read if I hadn't read Alive before it.

reply

There's a brief but very interesting intro to the book posted here:

https://genevalunch.com/2016/03/22/mountains-pedro-algorta/

and comments by Algorta himself in Cambridge on the eve of the book launch in the UK:

http://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/eat-human-flesh-Pedro-Algorta-surviving-Andes-air/story-28803513-detail/story.html

It will be fascinating to get his view on the events, as he has had little to say over the years (though he has talked about it, mostly in metaphorical terms, on his blog).

reply

Thanks! Now I need to order both books. By the way, I was fortunate enough to meet Eduardo Strauch about ten years ago. He was speaking in the states about the plane crash and ordeal. Another gentleman had found his wallet in the Andes while hiking (in the late 90s or early 2000s I believe). Eduardo was very kind, signed my copy of alive, and was gracious enough to let me take a photo with him. He struck me as very humble.

reply

He was speaking in the states about the plane crash and ordeal. Another gentleman had found his wallet in the Andes while hiking (in the late 90s or early 2000s I believe).


You might be interested in a longer account of the event:

http://www.eduardostrauch.com/site/index.php?module=hallazgo&lang=en

Since then, Eduardo and Mexican mountaineer Ricardo Pena have become close friends. They lead an annual pilgrimage to the crash site together, which sounds like a powerful and moving experience. I wish I could afford it (it's very reasonably priced, but not within my means). But there's info about it here:

http://www.alpineexpeditions.net/ricardos-connection-to-the-as.html

http://www.alpineexpeditions.net/andes-survivors-expedition.html

https://www.facebook.com/alpineexpeditions.net

Ricardo is also featured (as is Eduardo Strauch) on the History Channel documentary, "I am Alive." Rent or borrow the DVD, as I believe the extras have a bit more about them. You can probably find the documentary on YouTube.

reply

I am still listening to the book. It has taken me longer than I thought because I am not well. I am up to chapter 23 out of 54.

Canessa does not talk much about the other survivors, the book is mainly about him and Nando. As I said I am up to chapter 23 and they are into day 7 of their walk through the Andes.

The continuing search arranged by the families is quite interesting. At first it was being told by Canessa's father but now is being told by the search pilots.

reply

Palisade, that was the event where I saw Eduardo! Thanks for the links! I would absolutely LOVE to go on that trip. I would be a little scared, though. Maybe some day.

Miss Chicken. Is the book worth reading? Please let us know when you finish.

reply

I think that the book is worth reading mainly because it does cover details of the walk out that I haven't heard before.

The second half of the book deals with Canessa's life as a pediatic cardiologist and contains testimony from the parents of children he treated, as well as testimony from Canessa's children. It was interesting in that I learned a lot about heart conditions in new born children but I was a little annoyed at the hero worshipping of the parents (though I guess it is totally understandable).

I do wish that Canessa had covered some of the other people on the plane a bit more. In Nando's book we learned quite a bit about Guido Magri but Canessa's book is about Canessa.

I would 3.5 out of 5 but others might be more generous.

I am now waiting for Pedro's book to arrive.

reply

I should add that the coverage of the search conducted by the families also makes the book worth reading.

reply

Thanks for the review! And please keep us posted on Pedro's book! :)

reply

Ya I guess I might skip Canessa's, he was always an egomaniac apparently. Nando's book is alright, but goes too much into his personal home life, and the book is written with too many adjectives for a simple situation. But he does talk lot's about the others.

reply

I got Canessa's book from the library, and have read most of it. My take on it is a bit different from miss chicken's.

First off, though, I will agree with her that the book is not laid out in a narrative style, which must be considerably more difficult to follow in the audio version (as she did) than in the book version. With the book, you can flip back and forth if you need to check something, refer to the table of contents, etc. There was also an "Afterward" by co-author Pablo Vierci that would IMO have served well as a forward, because it explains how he and Canessa determined to write the book together, and how he, Vierci, got the stories of the other contributors, such as parents of Canessa's patients, people involved in the search, etc. When I saw how the book was broken up by chapters from these other people, I flipped to the back and read the afterward, which helped explain why and how those stories came to be included.

Another benefit to the book version were the pages of photographs, many of which I had not seen in any of the other books. There's a shot of Canessa and Nando on the occasion of Sergio Catalan's first trip to Uruguay as their guest, in 1975. There's a photo of Laura Canessa with their first child, Hilario, as a newborn (and a little explanation of how his name relates to the circumstances of the rescue), a family picture of Roberto and his 3 kids, all under age 10 or 11 at the time (by the looks of it), visiting Los Maitenes for the first time; Roberto and his 4 kids (young adults and/or older teens) in 2001 at the cross marking the burial site in the Valley of Tears, and some others, besides photos of the crash site that we have seen before.

I inferred from miss chicken's post that she was a bit disappointed that the book was about Roberto and not about the crash, rescue, other survivors, etc.

I did not feel that way, not at all. For one thing, I knew before I got the book that it was not about the crash, the rescue, the survivors: it was about Roberto's post-Andes life and how his experience on the mountain had shaped who he became and what he did with his life. That is made abundantly clear in the title itself: I HAD TO SURVIVE: How A Plane Crash in the Andes Inspired My Calling to Save Lives. That's exactly what the book is about, and for that reason, while it certainly helps to know the background story well, a reader could enjoy the book immensely knowing no more about the crash than what s/he picked up from the Wikipedia entries. The theme is about how the struggle to survive and get out alive influenced Roberto's personal and professional life in great and small ways thereafter.

While the story of the sixteen survivors and their ordeal is one of the most powerful narratives ever, I find their post-rescue lives to be as much or more inspiring: the way they have supported each other, in big and small ways, over the years. Their continued friendship and support of Sergio Catalan (and his family). Their making successes of their own lives, in a variety of ways, though some, like Carlitos, struggled with demons, but was helped by support (and a kick in the butt) by his friends. They did not end up on skid row, in treatment for PTSD, in fact all but Moncho Sabella, who married late, had children; even Javier had 4 more children with his second wife. Zerbino, in the extra on the DVD of Stranded, says that their story is one of love -- love for each other, their friends who they feel are constantly with them, and to and through whom their own children are inextricably linked.

So, I found Canessa's story of how he had turned his experience into a drive to save hopeless cases by becoming a pioneer in a new field of pediatric cardiology a gripping one. He hops back and forth in time to the trek out, of which he has vivid memories, and how he was inspired by that experience to tackle the impossible on a daily basis and "never give up," as his mother said she knew he would never do. He also reflects on how some of his less attractive qualities -- stubbornness, imperviousness to criticism, being pushy in getting his own way (and more besides) -- were actually invaluable assets in tackling the hopeless cases that presented themselves, and in keeping up his own spirits and those of the anxious parents of his tiny patients. To be constantly working with people in crisis, often dealing with tragedy and death, staying positive and yet realistic, takes a special sort of person.

Roberto's story is one of how the Andes tragedy shaped him into such a person.I am going to re-read it, as I have been going rather quickly through it the first time.

miss chicken mentioned the interesting parts about the searches for the survivors that were going on behind the scenes -- not much covered by Read's book or by any of the movies (except, to a slight extent, by Stranded). I enjoyed that, too, but a book with even more about the search, very interesting stuff too, is Clay Blair's book, Survive! Because the author did not have access to any of the survivors or their families when he wrote the book, it's an account of the accident and the days on the mountain that is full of inaccuracies. But what Blair did do was go to Chile and interview a lot of people with knowledge of the searches, the efforts of Canessa Sr., Nicolich Sr. and Harley Sr., Carlitos' dad, the moms who were in touch with a psychic, and much more. That part of his book is well-researched and very interesting, as is his information about the plane's navigational systems and some possible contributing factors to the accident that may have been the fault of ATC in Santiago. You can pick up that book as a used paperback on Amazon or alibris for a buck or two, and it's worth reading (just skip over the parts where the author doesn't really have good information. Read's book is hands down the source for the survivors' 72+ days in the Andes and their immediate post-rescue lives).







reply

While the story of the sixteen survivors and their ordeal is one of the most powerful narratives ever, I find their post-rescue lives to be as much or more inspiring: the way they have supported each other, in big and small ways, over the years.


I got Roberto's book on order. Your above statement is true for me as well. I really enjoyed Nando's book but it was while reading the epilogue and his description of the survivors lives afterwards that I thought he did an outstanding job. Especially when I got to the part about why after years of turning down opportunities to have his story told, he changed his mind. I read Nando's book not long after it came out but it wasn't till recently while I was going through a tough time that I remembered the one line from his book. "Everybody has their own personal Andes's". I dug the book out again and re-read it. I have no doubt that it helped me immensely and personally think it should be a part of every high schools curriculum. Some of the most inspirational stuff I've ever read.

reply

I will be buying the printed version and I might enjoy that more. At the beginning of the audiobook it does say there is a PDF that can be downloaded but I cannot find it on Audible at all. I think the photos would have been helpful in making the people in the book seem more real to me. Also, as Palisade said, the format of the book was not really suitable for an audiobook. I got the parents and children confused with each other especially as the voices of the female narrators were similar IMO.

I have never been that interested in medical stories (either on TV or in books) which is why I said other people would people might like the book more than I.

I also admit that I found, probably unfairly, the talk of God in the book a little grating as I am a 'devout atheist'

I have read 'Survive' and own a copy but haven't read it for many a year.

II will be interesting to see if I enjoy Pedro's book more, though I believe, at least at the tIme of the crash, Pedro was among the most religious in the group.

I loved Nando's book which if I remember correctly worked well as an audiobook.

EDITED TO ADD - I do wish Canessa's book was available as an e-book. My reason for choosing the audiobook over the printed version is failing eyesight - at least with a ebook I can change the font size.



reply

[deleted]

I really want to read it, hoping to soon. I've seen the documentary 'Stranded' though, absolutely fascinating.

reply