MovieChat Forums > Seong lung wui (1999) Discussion > funniest movie I have ever seen in my li...

funniest movie I have ever seen in my life


i swear to god, this movie was hilarious. it was so goofy and over the top and awful but in a funny way. i loved it

reply

...are you serious?

reply

*Gets hits with Glass*

OKAY!!

*Kicks everyones ass*

Funniest Action Line Ever

Old Ideas are Never the way of the Future; Unless they Adapt with the Times.

reply

LOL I just saw it for the first time tonight, loved it as well. One of my favorite Jackie Chan movies now (not counting American ones like Rush Hour, Shanghai series etc.)

I mean I like some of his other Chinese stuff a lot too like Rumble in the Bronx (probably one of my favorites, not sure why), Drunken Master 2, Mr. Nice Guy, Who Am I etc., but this one is great too, not sure why everyone hates on it. It's hilarious and has great action. I love when musician Jackie is in that big shootout just trying to stay alive and he starts driving that bus and it just gets all torn to heck, sooo funny.

Anyways, this movie is definitely better than some of his other stuff like Thunderbolt, which I also saw recently. THAT movie was dull. Had some great fight scenes but they were ruined by the director's use of near constant slow-motion (that wasn't even done well, it almost looked like the video was just poorly encoded or something), I could hardly believe how stupid they were to screw up the action with that horrible slow-motion effect.

Let's not even mention some of his crappy English movies like The Tuxedo and The Medallion, talk about horrible. Twin Dragons on the other hand was a real blast and one I would love to see again some day or even pick up on DVD sometime (I saw it on Netflix streaming). C'mon guys it's just a FUN movie. Get over yourselves! =)

reply

I agree, this movie rocked. I saw it for the first time last night. I was cracking up laughing!!!!

reply

This is by far Jackie's funniest movie.

reply

Really??. To each their own. I remember going to see it with a buddy cause the trailers were hilarious & both of us were bitterly disappointed. I think we might of walked out. But it was still better that Master Of Disguise. Those are the only two movies I've ever walked out of !!

reply

Pathetic thread, no one mentions that half of the world seen a very different version from the original.

With the horrible US dubbing (with Jackie Chan dubbing himself) the movie is sub par. With the original Cantonese audio it is at least an average movie, perhaps even good in its genre.

reply


With the horrible US dubbing (with Jackie Chan dubbing himself) the movie is sub par. With the original Cantonese audio it is at least an average movie, perhaps even good in its genre.


I disagree, I have seen both the dub and original version (and currently do not even had the dub version) and found the dub version to be a lot funnier, it also cut some useless/unfunny scenes.

Also, another funny Jackie chan movie is Operation Condor 2.... Or if you want something less serious you might like City Hunter.

-----------
Dont be lazy, use the [quote ] [/ quote] tag.

reply

It tells a lot you're saying "Operation Condor 2". You've probably seen the dubbed versions first, fell in love with them (for lack of a better version), then it doesn't matter anymore if you see the superior original versions, you'll always find the first versions funny, or even funnier.

Every dub I can recall that was done by Jackie Chan in the US, is poorly translated and acted. Watch the original Cantonese, people.

reply

It tells a lot you're saying "Operation Condor 2"


How so? It has so many funny parts. But unlike Twin dragon, Operation Condor 2 is as funny in both the dub and original.

You've probably seen the dubbed versions first, fell in love with them (for lack of a better version), then it doesn't matter anymore if you see the superior original versions, you'll always find the first versions funny, or even funnier.


Many jackie movies ive first seen dub, so that is true, but that does not effect my decision all that much. If anything I am more likely to like the original version because its longer. Overall I tend to find the dub funnier, but sometimes the original is funnier. Looking at Twin dragon ill give you two examples:

Better in the English version: There isnt that unfunny scene were Rocky is asking Jackie to train him. I found that very unfunny and wasteful.

Better in the original version: When a bad guy is fighting the weak jackie in the car plant and starts winning he is convinced its his kicks that are really good and allowing him to win, in the sub he just thinks he is a stronger fighter.

Every dub I can recall that was done by Jackie Chan in the US, is poorly translated and acted.

Some arent done all that great, but still worth it (hearing a sub par voice actor is better then me reading text). It can also be more fun watching the movie and listen to a dub rather then reading subs and missing parts of the movie.

Watch the original Cantonese, people.
Almost all my jackie chan movies are in the original Cantonese, I only have them because I am a bit of a purist and like the 'original' and the best PQ... That being said, most movies are both funnier and have better flow in the english version (and Twin Dragon definitely falls into this category imo).

I guess my question to you is if you understand Cantonese? Because if that is the case, then I could definitely understand why you would find them funnier.


-----------
Dont be lazy, use the [quote ] [/ quote] tag.

reply

I don't speak Cantonese, I have to read subtitles too.

I know plenty of good dubs in the movie history, but none of Jackie Chan's US dubs qualifies for one reason: Jackie's voice performances are always poor. How could anyone give a good performance in a foreign language? It's close to impossible, especially if you don't speak the language too well anyway. And this is only the biggest problem with those dubs.

hearing a sub par voice actor is better then me reading text

Now that is the problem here.

You prefer it dubbed even if the dub is actually worse, because you don't like to read subtitles. It's your call, but don't propagate that those dubs are better than the original sound, please.

reply

Now that is the problem here.

You prefer it dubbed even if the dub is actually worse, because you don't like to read subtitles. It's your call, but don't propagate that those dubs are better than the original sound, please.


The dubs are better for me, as they increase my overall experience and enjoyment. If I read a sub, I read it in a monotone voice in my head, while if its a dub at worse I will get the same effect as me reading it, at best the dubs can be delivered/acted in a way I could never read it.

Also even if some voice actors are rather bad, sometimes that in itself adds to the fun.

Between anime (even dbz, which I started with dubs but prefer subs), jackie chan and a few other foreign films I read a lot of subs. I got no problem with subs. I just find overall my experience is better with jackie chan dubs in many movies. I'm sure the average English speaking person would mostly vote for the dubs too.

-----------
Dont be lazy, use the [quote ] [/ quote] tag.

reply