MovieChat Forums > Lektionen in Finsternis (2002) Discussion > What other films can you compare this on...

What other films can you compare this one to?


After we saw this film at our local film center (the last in a series of Herzog films presented), we were priviledged to have as guest speaker an Associate Professor of Film from a local college to discuss it with us. He enlighted as to the relationship between Herzog and Paul Berriff, the chief cinematographer. Berriff was already on the scene and Herzog eventually teamed up with him. It is interesting to note that whatever cinematographer Herzog uses, or whatever the limitations or difficulties of filming, one can always "feel" that one is watching one of his film. Other interesting facts concerned the limitations of where the helicopter pilot could fly due to the extreme heat of the fires (up to 1000 degrees Fahrenheit); yet another dangerous environment in which the making of the film was as much an event as the final product itself.

Somewhere during our after-film chat it occurred to me that there was a similar feel to this film and "The Road Warrior" in regard to the dominant imagery of forward movement across an apocalypic landscape; deep, intoning narration; and the dramatic alteration of exhileration and horror that only such an environment could engender. Our speaker found a relation to "Hiroshima Mon Amour," which I have not seen.

I would also suggest that there is no other filmaker who better incorporates music with images. This film may be his finest example.


"Gentles, perchance you wonder at this show;
But wonder on, till truth make all things plain."
-- A Midsummer Night's Dream

reply

And of course Fata Morgana is similar to this. I've seen Hiroshima Mon Amour and the connection does make sense. You should check it out.

My top 20:
http://www.ymdb.com/tyler-ludowitz/l28735_ukuk.html

reply

Throughout I noted similarities to '2001: A Space Odyssey'. To me, they are remarkably closely linked.

reply

[deleted]

Herzog has said that he envisions his three films, "Fata Morgana," "Lessons of Darkness," and "The Wild Blue Yonder," as a trilogy. They're all science-fiction recastings of footage to incredible music, with a view toward providing an estranged and hence clearer view of life on Earth. "The Wild Blue Yonder" is a sort of antidote to "Lessons of Darkness," with a utopian ending. Herzog had the music created first and then edited the film to conform to the music. It's a really interesting contrast to "Lessons of Darkness," though I think "Lessons of Darkness" is more powerful.

reply


^ This.

Please nest your IMDB page, so you respond to the correct person.

reply

I think Koyaanisqatsi is a bit similar to this one. It's a lot of the same stuff. Nice pictures with music to set the mood..

reply

[deleted]

I'm with you on this one. Lessons In Darkness reminded me of Sans Soleil.

reply

It somewhat reminded me of Baraka (1992). The subject matter is quite different but at least the focus on visuals with an imho great soundtrack could be compared.

reply

I suggest watching Manufactured Landscapes. It is a documentary about the effects of massive industrial processes. It focuses on China but it also shows sites around the world.

reply

Koyaanisqatsi.
Powaqqatsi.
Naqoyqatsi.
Baraka.

Personally I think Koyaanisqatsi is the film of this kind. There's also an upcoming one called Samsara.

reply

[deleted]