MovieChat Forums > Kurenai no buta (1994) Discussion > Suitable for young children?

Suitable for young children?


Hi,

My niece loved Ponyo and Totoro.

Is there anything unsuitable in this film to warrant the 'PG' or is it fairly safe?


Thanks for your thoughts.

reply

Well, Invision, there's nothing that a normal person would deem 'unsuitable', I don't think, but it isn't a film intended for children; Miyazaki has said that he created it for weary businessmen. I understand that the American dub has 'jollied it up' for family audiences, how ghastly. Why not watch it yourself first and then decide?

reply

I'd say it's safe- just remember though that this film has the oldest target audience of all his work. It certainly won't connect with her on the same level as Ponyo and Totoro. I'd probably recommend Kiki's Delivery Service or Spirited Away for now, maybe show her Porco Rosso when she's a bit older, say 10 or so.

reply

Yes. I imagine the only reason its rated PG is because there are Machine guns in it. No ne is killed on screen and the few people that are killed fly off to heaven.

Illusions Micheal..illusions...tricks are something that a whore does for money.....or Cocaine

reply

I remember there was also some bad language.

reply

It's PG.

reply

We just watched it with our 7-year-old son, who loved the airplane scenes. There is a fist-fight that deal some bruises, but no big deal. It should be fine.

reply

Thank you for asking this question; I wanted to know the same thing!

Oh, that I had time to pre-watch every movie I might like to share with my children. We've already been through Totoro (about 50 times), Ponyo, and Kiki, as well as Spirited Away and Whisper of the Heart. Plus Takahata's Pom Poko for good measure.

This actually sounds less disturbing to a 4-year-old than Nausicaa or Princess Mononoke. But maybe we'll try Howl's Moving Castle first.

reply

My son has watched several Ghibli/Miyasaki films (many times). Porco Rosso is one of his favorites. He is now 5 years old.

--- Once Upon a Time in the West ---
Keep your loving brother happy! - Frank

reply

Yes it is definetly suitable for young children. There is nothing in the movie that is really disturbing or innapropiate for a young child.

reply

apart from the brutal fist fight at the end and Porco's smoking

reply