MovieChat Forums > The Distinguished Gentleman (1992) Discussion > Do powerlines really cause cancer?

Do powerlines really cause cancer?


Like it showed in the movie?

reply

They never said that in the movie, remember when Loretta tells Johnson that some say they do, some say it's just a coincidence. But I think authorities agree that high voltage lines may cause cancer, but of course within a certain distant, I wouldn't know about the lines shown in the movie, they seemed pretty high from ground. Nevertheless they made a good point.

reply

I doubt if anyone can say for certain whether EMAG fields can cause cancer, but this movie was made in 1992. I didn't really even hear about such things until 10 years later. Cellphones brought this issue to a head recently (and it still remains a huge health question today).

Great movie. Still current after 20 years.

It was good to see some great actors when they were younger. And RIP Kevin McCarthy.

reply

It was good to see some great actors when they were younger. And RIP Kevin McCarthy.


and r.i.p Lane Smith. (uh huh)













Take your pinche color-coordinated sponsored chingada and take a flying fck

reply

Power lines do not cause cancer.

A study was done at one point which showed higher rates of cancer in neighborhoods which contained high tension power lines. But the author of the study himself said there was likely no causation. He believed the correlation was because the lines lower property values, so those neighborhoods tend to be occupied by lower-income families. Lower-income people are statistically more likely to have cancer. These facts combined to make it appear that power lines caused cancer. It is a classic example that shows correlation does not mean causation. Of course, that did not stop the media from running with the story.

The power line-cancer link was conclusively disproven when a study of power line workers showed no increased occurance of cancer. Those people work up-close with power lines every day and it didn't affect them.

As for another comment which compared power lines to cell phones, there is no common element beteen the two. Cell phones produce microwave and radio wave radiation, while power lineage generate magnetic fields.

reply

Workers here are being energized and immersed in a 500,000 volt field and sitting right on top the live wires.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tzga6qAaBA

reply

" Lower-income people are statistically more likely to have cancer."
People living in poverty are also more likely to die from cancer than their more affluent peers because they do not have access to high quality cancer prevention, early detection, and treatment services.

reply

"The power line-cancer link was conclusively disproven when a study of power line workers showed no increased occurance of cancer. Those people work up-close with power lines every day and it didn't affect them."

In the film they say it's children who are affected the most, supposedly for being more frail. Workers are adults, supposed to better withstand those magnetic field.

reply

The movie was made at the time when the media was making a big deal about power lines or before any real studies were done. If the movie was made at a different time. They probably would have picked something else.

reply

[deleted]