Did I totally miss the ending?


It's really bothering me that I didn't get "it" so she finds the board in the ocean without him why? did he get dragged back to work and didn't get a chance to grab it or did he just leave it there? And the montage at the end seems more of a retrospective to me so what should I be assuming about those two.. I feel kind of dumb ;( Anybody want to enlighten me? thanks

reply

Of what I make of it he was swept out to sea. Considering in the last scene it was a very bad day weatherwise. In that case it could have been either suicide or just natural. Thats my take on it.

reply

I didn't get the ending either. I think he died by accident, and then she took the board, took it to Chiba and commited suicide. It all happened so sudden, was it really necessary that they die? They died for no reason, that's what I hate about Kitano movies, we never know why the characters die.

reply

This is just my take on it, but I think Kitano employed Shigeru's death as a metaphor.

Before he discovered that broken, discarded Blue Bunny board - he just stared blankly at the sea.

Once he taped the Blue Bunny together and tried to learn how to surf, Shigeru was coming alive when he was learning to do something he was passionate about. Shigeru hardly ever smiled or showed emotion in any scenes except when he was on the beach or surfing

He showed more dedication, passion and love for the sport (ie - surfing without a wetsuit, surfing when waves / weather were poor, taking his girlfriend for granted, missing work, entering a surfing contest while still a beginner, carefully studying the other surfers) than the group of other "surfer dudes" who are shown mostly just sitting on their asses, laughing at Shigeru and never really seeming to bond with or understand him.

So, its VERY POETIC (and more tragic) that Shigeru died doing the one thing that gave him the most joy and made him feel the most alive - surfing.

reply


I don't know where you the idea that SHE (Takako) committed suicide - I've just re-watched the last scenes again, and there's no indication (implicit or otherwise) that she died at all.

The last scene of her is when she took his board to Chiba, taped the picture of the two of them together, then let the tides wash it out so that his spirit could continue to do what he loved.

The guy with the truck (played by Susumu Terajima) was waiting at the edge of the beach for her - so I'd doubt that he'd just sit by and let her commit suicide.

reply

She did not commit suicide, and if she did then not because of his death. Well what I'm saying is, the ending does not imply she is committing suicide at all.

reply

No, don't feel dumb.

I'm a Japanese Canadian (who's lived for a few years in Japan) and I suppose its a cultural intuition thing, but he most certainly died at sea.

I will admit that I was a little confused at first. How he died is vague, but the weather was bad that morning (she was carrying an umbrella), so it was likely an accident.

There really wouldn't be any reason for her to take his surfboard out to sea if he were still alive. It was a memorial - she took his surfboard, taped a picture of the two of them on it. The surfboard was carried out by the tides so that his spirit could enjoy doing what he loved most in the place where he accomplished so much (the contest beach).

You are correct, the montage is a retrospective. (although it looks like a bunch of outtakes & deleted scenes from the rest of the movie)

The last two chapter titles on the North American DVD (before the End Credits) are called "The Last Wave" (when he dies) and "Memories" (the retrospective)

reply

Yes, he really died...and it makes sense...at least to me!Therefore, i think he killed himself because he already had achieved what he wanted - to prove himself (and maybe others) that he could become a good surfer with his effort, despite his physical issue.His life was meaningless, and the sea was his only real passion.Once he gained the award, it was his personal achievement that completed him,because it was the only thing that interested him.He really intended to die in the place he loved - the sea.But the fact the weather was bad when he did it, was irrelevant.Another movie that has a similar ending is Point Break, with Keanu Reeves and Patrick Swayze, where the character played by Swayze goes to the stormy sea to die, because he preferred to die in the freedom of the sea he loved to surf,than to go to jail...Maybe thereĀ“s a connection between these two movies...In A Scene at the Sea, maybe Shigeru preferred to die in the sea than to go back to his real life that was meaningless and depressing.The movies were also made almost at the same time...

reply

I understood that surfing was a metaphor for the relationship between the two main characters. I don't think he dies, he just leaves the board.

The main character at first is really excited about surfing. He gets obsesed. He then relaxes a bit, but still cares about the sport. Finally, he quits. These are all phases in a relationship, their relationship.

reply

[deleted]

There's no doubt in my mind that he died. The only question is whether it was intentional or not. Chances are it was.

reply

Well, i must confess... When i watched this movie the first time - i understood Shigeru's disappearance as a break in their relationship. I thought: summer is over, he is not riding the board anymore and that is an end to their relationship. I didn't know much about Takeshi then...

And yesterday i watched it again. Now i saw all Takeshi's movies (as director). And now i clearly understand the surfboard without Shigeru as an accident... So he died in the sea...

Anyway it's a great movie! And as i missed the plot the 1st time - i still enjoyed it then, and enjoyed it now and will enjoy it again one day!

Thank you, Takeshi!

reply

I think he became a snack of Jaws or Orca. No, he died at the stormy sea (remember the dark clouds and rain at that particular scene). I doubt that he comitted suicide as the other posters here implied; since he also love the girl like he loves surfing (remember the scene where he goes to the girl's house because she started not seeing him - Director Kitano is implying that he also has some passion for the girl. Now why would he kill himself if they have a good lasting relationship and having a good time surfing. Another thing: the girl didn't commit suicide as a couple of posters here implied. This is pure speculation. If this is the case one could even speculate that the girl shack-up with the driver of the pick-up truck (remember her smile at the driver). There was no indication in the film that she committed Sepuku! Kitano was just finishing his story arc with a poignant conclusion.

reply

[deleted]

lolz He comes to the beach everyday no matter how bad the weather is. Remember there was always a group of people playing football near the beach. The day he came to the beach, there was no-one there. Dark clouds filled up the sky. Remember he has hearing impair and he live with no-one but his girlfriend. They always come to the beach together. But "that day" the girl follow him from the distant. She perhaps was trying to stop him going to the beach. Before the memorial scenes, there is a scene where his co-worker was working with another guy. lolz I don't know if u understand what I am trying to say.

In other words, the raining day in the last scenes probably indicated a storm. Since he was hearing impaired, he couldn't hear the weather forecast neither his girlfriend. And he went to the beach as usual. He was swept away by the sea. Another dustman came and worked with his ex co-worker.

reply

Although everything else points to the fact that he didn't die - one thing that does is he is replaced by a different worker partner for the trash guy. The whole meaning of the movie pretty much points the other way - that he just left the surfboard there and quit.

reply

Just leave the point that he's gone and no matter how. Died or broke up with girlfriend or quit surfing or anything ...

And his girlfriend, seemed to be happy(perhaps she pretended). She smiled at the truck driver at Chiba, I don't know why. But she sounded not in much sorrow and mourning, just linger.

reply

[deleted]

He died, in the stormy ocean.

To understand the film, you need to realize that one of its aesthetic pillars, like with many of Kitano's other films, is the concept of "mono no aware". While this is notoriously difficult to describe or translate, it is essentially an aesthetic concept that refers to the transient beauty of things, with an implication of sadness.

A common example would be the blooming of sakura (cherry blossoms). Their beauty does not lie merely in their visual qualities, but also in the fact that the blossoms only last for a short while. The sadness of their rapidly approaching "death" adds to their appeal, and has often been used as a symbol for human mortality.

In a sense, you could say that in "Scene at the Sea", you watched the blossoming of his life, as well as its end. This blossoming, however, is not the kind of "grandiosity" you often see in American film. Rather, it is a normal life filled with numerous small struggles and fleeting tragedies - but also true happiness.

Of course, the film could have had a different ending. But that would have detracted, in a way, from the transient beauty of the summer shown in the film.

reply

[deleted]