Matthew was Roy


Does anyone else think that Quigley actually could have been Roy Cobb regretting sending his wife to Australia, so he took the next boat to Aus to try to find her?????

Just a thought.

reply

No.

reply

Nope.

reply

no he clearly has no clue who this crazy woman is that keeps calling him Roy.

reply

Absolutly............NOT!

reply

I could see why you would think that... But no, they were similar in appearance (according to her) but as you could tell, she was missing a few marbles... and as stated above, he had no idea what she was talking about.

"Well if there's gunna be any shooting, I gotta get my rest."

reply

Hi,
I do not know; I did not see the movie. However, I saw like two seconds off it, before my Cousin's Grandma changed the channle.

Peace,
Amanda

reply

This may very well be the funniest message board post i have ever read.

reply

Thank you... rosebud, how nice of you to voice that very important opinion...

"Well if there's gunna be any shooting, I gotta get my rest."

reply

[deleted]

Roy was from Texas. Matthew Quigley was from Montana. Cora was a few fries short of a happy meal.

reply

Wyoming.

..Joe

reply

Rosebud,

What did you see during those 2 seconds of it? Was it awesome? Did you ever find out why your cousin's grandma changed the channel?

Now that you are 12 years older, has your view of those 2 seconds changed? Or did they change your life in general?

Thanks in advance, Rosebud!

reply

A romantic thought, but NO!

reply

I'm glad Rosebud cleared that up for us. Now, back to the original post.
NO.

reply

no

reply

Not a chance.

reply

Don't let it trouble you Rosebud200320,

I have your Cousin's Grandma lined up in the verneer sight of my lever action breach loading modified 34 inch Sharpe rifle right now. She seems to be hesitating in a fog of senility with her withered right paw resting on the channel switching dial, just say the word.

By the way, which 2 seconds did you happen to see?



reply

I don't think so.

reply

[deleted]

Let me think...hmmm.....NO

My...my...ain't you purty, and just look at them shiny shoes!

reply

Nice thought, but I don't think so because of the way Mathew acted and reacted throughout the whole movie. He has no reason to deny who he is even if he was Roy Cobb.

reply

what about what cora said at the end though? how does that play into things?

If anyone asks, there were fifty of them...and they were rattlesnakes.~ Diego

reply

Remind me, what did she say?

reply

somethin' like 'remember when you said you'd make love to me i had to say two words... matthew quigley."' that's not exact b/c i can't remeber it all, but it gets the opint across

If anyone asks, there were fifty of them...and they were rattlesnakes.~ Diego

reply

no way.....matthew would have never put her on a boat....

reply

He said that when her and Matthew were camped out together. In fact it's more proof he wasn't Roy, because he wanted her to stop calling him that before they slept together.

Feel me?

reply

The chance that Matthew Quigley was actually Roy Cobb is about as good as the chance that Liberty Valance actually shot himself.

reply

You know, I think the original poster is onto something... nah.. not really. NO!

reply

If you listen to a fool long enough they will finally bring you down to their level.

reply

Quigley told Cora that before he would share his bed with anyone, she had to know who she was with. THAT'S why she said, "Matthew Quigley." To show him she knew who he was.


I don't have hot flashes. I have short, private vacations in the tropics.

reply