Useless piece of crap


Did this movie accomplish anything aside from getting several of its cast members hooked on drugs? Totally useless.

reply

wha....it told a beautiful story. Isn't that enough?

I'm a connoisseur of roads. I've been tasting roads my whole life.

reply

This movie never should've been made.

reply

Agreed

reply

River Phoenix made the choice to do heroine...that is a fact. No one made him do it and I don't believe anyone could have stopped him. River Phoenix was just that type of actor. Everything had to be authentic to him.

The kid was doomed from the start.

If he had stayed in mainstream Hollywood films, don't you think he would have come across heroine eventually??

There wasn't really much hope for a kid like him in a place like Hollywood.

My Own Private Idaho was a good film and told a story about something real and painful. I respect the director for doing what he could to make it authentic. I don't really respect the choices actors make to get into their roles however.

reply

River made some bad decisions, yes. Apparently, he wanted to star in The Basketball Diaries too, so if not for MOPI, that role could've led to his demise also. But what about poor Rodney Harvey? Keanu was supposedly doing heroin too, but I don't really care about him. lol

reply

River made some bad decisions, yes. Apparently, he wanted to star in The Basketball Diaries too, so if not for MOPI, that role could've led to his demise also. But what about poor Rodney Harvey? Keanu was supposedly doing heroin too, but I don't really care about him. lol


I don't really think this is a good reason to call the film a piece of crap though. I mean yes it was terrible that some kid introduced him to heroin...but ultimately he said yes and stuck the needle in his arm. It's kind of a tragedy if you consider where he came from and how much acting meant to him.

I don't say this as an apologist or some type of militant anti drug crusader.

My brother is a heroin addict. He had a pretty rotten childhood, but he was like River in a way. Kind of the leader of our family unit, took on a lot of the burden of our household. He always tried to protect me in the best we he could and the only he knew how to. But that is a lot of responsibility for an 8-12 year old child. I used to think that if someone could have done something to help him early on, then things would have turned out differently.

If only my dad wasn't an alcoholic....if only he didn't hit him and berate him and pick at him. If only my mom had packed our bags and left him long ago. If only he had grown up in a better neighborhood and he had surrounded himself with better people.

Truth of the matter, was that this lifestyle and curiosity was always a part of him and I strongly believe that it was a part of who River Phoenix was. From interviews and personal anecdotes we know that River was a deep thinker, that he was quiet, reserved, introverted.

My brother is kind of the opposite, a thrill seeker, always wanted to be the center of attention, lives for new sensations and experiences.

I don't know, it bums me out to think about River. The one thing I do enjoy is watching this performance from him, it's probably his best performance.

reply

Understanding the reasoning is huge and I'd say 99.9% of addicts would tell you tje same(Whether they're still using or not)...

People CHOOSE to use drugs, that's a fact... But addiction is something never fully understood unless you've lived it. I HAVE. Nobody plans to be a scumbag.

Childhood issues, anxiety, depression, abuse etc, I mean, there are a million reasons people become addicted. Rich or poor, black or white. When I read about Phoenix and his youth, I 100% understood why he became an addict. Atleast from an ex users perspective anyway... Yes, he became successful but nobody knows what was inside of his head everyday. The FILM IS NOT TO BLAME! That is the dumbest *beep* I've ever heard. People always talk down on addicts until they or a loved one becomes one. I feel for your brother or anyone else, its an epidemic where I live. Southeastern Massachusetts, I live in a tough City and it's dirt cheap. It's all around you everyday and unfortunately,all it takes is an uunderlying issue to make you take that first hit... The game never ends after that. Phoenix was no different. Success doesn't immune people to real life problems

reply

Understanding the reasoning is huge and I'd say 99.9% of addicts would tell you tje same(Whether they're still using or not)...

People CHOOSE to use drugs, that's a fact... But addiction is something never fully understood unless you've lived it. I HAVE. Nobody plans to be a scumbag.

Childhood issues, anxiety, depression, abuse etc, I mean, there are a million reasons people become addicted. Rich or poor, black or white. When I read about Phoenix and his youth, I 100% understood why he became an addict. Atleast from an ex users perspective anyway... Yes, he became successful but nobody knows what was inside of his head everyday. The FILM IS NOT TO BLAME! That is the dumbest *beep* I've ever heard. People always talk down on addicts until they or a loved one becomes one. I feel for your brother or anyone else, its an epidemic where I live. Southeastern Massachusetts, I live in a tough City and it's dirt cheap. It's all around you everyday and unfortunately,all it takes is an uunderlying issue to make you take that first hit... The game never ends after that. Phoenix was no different. Success doesn't immune people to real life problems


Most definitely. Well said btw.

It's odd to think that my brother and I had essentially the same childhood experiences except one of us ended up an addict and the other one did not.

I believe Joaquin has had issues with alcohol (although he seems to have some control over this), but I have to wonder about his other siblings. I imagine some of them did not turn into addicts.

reply

You can not like the movie if you want, but it's ridiculous to think it got River Phoenix or anyone else hooked on heroin. There's nothing about heroin in this movie (unlike "Drugstore Cowboy")and young people at that time (and perhaps just as much now) were just into the "glamour" of heroin use. You can't blame Gus Van Sant for that. Phoenix's drug problems may have pre-dated this role for all anyone knows. And if heroin use was supposed to be some kind of "method acting" tool, it doesn't really even fit THIS movie. Besides, as Stella Adler once said, "You don't have to die to play a dead man".

None of the cast of "Drugstore Cowboy" became heroin addicts, despite the subject matter of that movie. And Corey Haim became a drug addict and died young in spite of appearing in nothing, but trite, mainstream happy-crappy Hollywood garbage.

"Let be be finale of seem/ The only emperor is the Emperor of Ice Cream"

reply


How dare you say Corey Haim did nothing good! The Lost Boys is one of my favourite movies. In all honesty though, I'm struggling to the of anything else he was in that was not mediocre.

reply

I don't believe that Keanu was/is a drug addict,his father when to prison because he was a drug pusher.

reply

that bad?

reply