MovieChat Forums > Hook (1991) Discussion > Pan should have died at the end.

Pan should have died at the end.


I finally figured out what's wrong with this movie.

Everyone knows it missed the mark, somehow, Spielberg himself is infamously dissatisfied with it... Although personally it is one of my top 10 all time favorite movies, bar none.

But EVEN I admit , although the cinematography is great, the sound effects, the acting (Robin Williams is literally a gift to watch) The music, the SETS, EVERYTHING is great except it just seems to miss the mark. I think it's the ending, which is clearly the weakest point.

When Tink sprinkles her dust over Pan's kids at the end... and they all fly away in happiness ... You just left with a feeling of emptiness.

I think Peter should have died, NOT Rufio in the end fight.

But OF COURSE this would NEVER be allowed by Disney , least of all in an early 90s Disney children's film (maybe in their weird 80s flicks like Return to Oz, but not in the 90's).

Spielberg was IMO crippled by Disney's 'family' ethic , he MUST have thought of this plot element at some point, but would have known it wouldn't be allowed.

I think my Pan dying idea is solidified by one of the most famous lines from the original Pan play "To Die would be an awfully big adventure".


---
in the beginning, it is always dark

reply

He must have thought of this plot element? How would you know that exactly? It sounds like you're trying to project your own fan fiction to something Speilberg would have done which is just ludicrous. In order for Peter Pan to die, the entire tone and target audience of the film would have to change. It's not even about Disney not allowing something like that, it's more about common sense not allowing such a thing because that's entirely illogical. Rufio's death was a plot device to setup the big final battle between hero and villian. Rufio's death was able to be done because the main hero ended up defeating the villian.

reply

This wasn't a Disney movie, so that kind of hampered a lot of your argument about Disney not allowing it to happen

reply