I'm so glad...
I'm so glad I grew up in a less cynical time when we were able to suspend our disbelief and just go along for the ride at the movies.
In my opinion, this is a great, entertaining film. It obviously (and deliberately) pays homage to other films and styles of the past, going back to Citizen Kane.
Doyle's score is surely not subtle... but I think it is amazing and works brilliantly for this type of film.
Just the opening montage with the Newspaper headline screaming MURDER was enough to hook me through the movie.
Does it have plot holes... sure. Is the dual life/re-incarnation angle realistic? Of course not.
But in the words of ... I believe it was Samuel Goldwyn... "If I want to see reality, I'll look out the window"
This is an old Hollywood stylized movie with fun twists, and a great "what if" premise.
I think the overly critical viewers should lighten up and try to enjoy this movie (and other Older films) for what they are.