I realize this post is old and likely the OP will never see this but I wanted to respond anyway.
The ending scene when Mike goes from unconscious to fighting form? Yeah...no. I suppose you could argue adrenalin rush but even that is pushing it.
Eh, this basically happens in all movies. Almost every action movie has people making miraculous rebounds and recoveries from horrid injuries in a totally unrealistic way. Additionally, he could have been faking just how out of it he was. Either way, it's kind of a lame complaint but if it bothered you that much then fair enough.
In every way Amanda/Grace has the thoughts and memories of Margaret but she's actually Roman. I like that she's Roman, it just wasn't consistent.
You are actually incorrect on this. Grace was never Margaret and never had Margaret's memories. She was remembering the events as a spectator or witness, not as an actual player (even if that's what she was in reality). This is pretty explicitly explained when Frankie hypnotizes her and tells her to distance herself from the things she is seeing. All of her narration of the past events is in the third person, not from the POV of either Margaret or Roman. Even the last time she goes under and says Mike was there and he was "going to kill me" she is simply mixing up the past and present, which again is pretty clearly stated by Frankie immediately after she makes the comment. Her nightmares before the hypnosis are the only thing that can even possibly be viewed as an implication that she is Margaret but even at that, they are just nightmares of the situation. And even if she were Margaret in the dreams...so what? Dreams are dreams and are not always clear.
When Frankie puts Mike under hypnosis he tells him that he is not a witness but he is there as the person he really was and he asks him to tell him who he is which is why he immediately and clearly sees himself as Margaret.
It's fine if you did not like the film but some of the things you point out are not actually errors, they are simply your own short-comings and misunderstanding.
"Why couldn't the monkey arrange this from INSIDE the garbage can?"
reply
share