MovieChat Forums > Class Action (1991) Discussion > Some scenes don't fit ... but still a g...

Some scenes don't fit ... but still a good movie


Mastrantonio (Maggie Ward) and Hackman (Jebediah Ward) do a good job of portraying father/daughter attornies who wind up on the opposing side of a class action suit. It's a good plot and the drama plays well throughout the movie. What I got tired of was the topic of infidelity that became a sub-plot in a drama story that already had its fair share of sub plots. The infidelity is introduced following the unexpected death of Mrs. Ward (Estelle). Following her death there's a scene with Jebediah and Maggie and we learn that Jebediah had an affair with his wife's best friend years ago and his daughter, Maggie, knew about it and that became a source of emotional pain for her. Maggie mentions this as they were reminising over photos they found in a box. Accusations fly as Maggie vilifies her dad for his infidelity. Jebediah does his best to explain why but Maggie doesn't want to hear it. So other then a daughter expressing her repugnance for her dads unfaithfulness I saw connection to the over all story. All we learned is Jebediah had an affair and Maggie knew about it. I was hoping for a connection but nothing materialized.
Other then those scenes that don't appear to fit I recommend the movie for the exceptional acting and some good court room drama.

reply

I think you'll find, mloessel, that the backstory was an attempt to give depth to the relationship issues between opposing lawyers, thus making the final denouement more of a surprise, perhaps.

Whether it did or not is another issue!

reply

Maggie did not trust her Dad and neither did she trust Grazier once Grazier decided to hide the research notes. Maggie refused to be anyone's whore and Grazier's belief that Maggie would do anything to hurt her father backfired on him and the firm.

reply

Without the backstory, if Maggie acted spiteful toward her father for no good reason, the viewer would think she was a b***h. Presumably, the film could have been made with a loving father/daughter relationship, but the antagonism gives it another dimension.

reply

Yeah, I think those scenes had to be there. Otherwise, if the father/daughter had a perfect relationship with no reason for conflict, they might never have ended up on opposite sides of the lawsuit. There had to be motivating conflict in the relationship in order for the story to work.

Saw it today for the first time. Was a pretty good movie.

reply