MovieChat Forums > Átame! (1990) Discussion > Proving The Fact The MPAA Is Too Tight

Proving The Fact The MPAA Is Too Tight


Censorship destroys art, I can't see how anyone would agree with the MPAA.

"No it is not a "LOL" moment, it is a "lol" moment."

reply

Censorship destroys art, I can't see how anyone would agree with the MPAA.

Putting a rating on a film is not censorship. Huge difference.

reply

[deleted]

It's not direct censorship but it's a roundabout way of attempting to force an artist to change something. Anything over an R rating almost ensures that a movie will only be picked up by a lesser known distributor. At least, that used to be the case. Thank you, Netflix.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
http://infinityburst.wordpress.com/

reply

yea this is so not an NC-17 level film this should have gotten an R of course i don't think anything should get an NC-17

reply

A rating IS censorship when the MPAA knows perfectly well that NC17 will keep theatres from showing the film. It's a disguised form of censorship. Just like a store saying they won't sell CDs with parental advisory labels on them.

The message to the artists is clear: "Censor your own art, or we will prevent you from making money." The artists, or studio heads, then make cuts. The art suffers. And the MPAA or whoever says, "Don't blame us. We didn't make them cut their work." When, in reality, they forced them to by threatening to prevent them a wide release. That is what happens when artists refuse to censor "controversial" art. And that is the hope of the narrow minded individuals who impose these rules and believe they speak for everyone.


"Now, where was I?"-Leonard Shelby

reply

[deleted]

It's the decision of parents and parents alone what their children can or cannot watch. NC17 is a rating that takes that decision away from them. Period.


"Now, where was I?"-Leonard Shelby

reply

Parents can't make a decision if there isn't a rating to guide them. Or are they supposed to view every film that's out there before they decide what their kid can watch? That would be a little time consuming, don't you think?

reply

Frankly, parenting always is time consuming. So if you don't have the time to do it, then don't have children.

With resources like the internet and IMDB.com it is easy enough though. You don't need ratings to tell you what to do. If you have children and they want to see a movie, type the title in a search box, press Enter and see what sort of movie it is. Then make up your mind.

Or better yet, watch the movie together with them, so you can discuss it with them during or after the show.

Átame, in my opinion, could be used as a good educational movie to see with teenagers of 12-13 years and up. Assuming that they are not still in the dark about all matters of sexuality, in other words, they have not missed out on a correct sexual education. While watching you can make the point that although the movie treats the subject in a funny and lighthearted way, this is clearly NOT the proper way to pursue a romantic and/or sexual relationship with someone. Also don't forget to counter this movie with movies that give better examples.

If Átame were a much darker movie, meaning more violent/grim/explicit, then I would not show it to young teenagers. But as it is, I think they should be able to handle (and enjoy/giggle about) the light sexuality in this movie. While still seeing that something is wrong in how the hapless characters act.

The scuba diver scene that caused such an uproar is just endearingly cute, it is completely harmless for all ages. Especially compared to some other sh!t that they will probably encounter on the web nowadays. Which would have me more worried really.

reply

It proves that MPAA is the most corrupt rating system in the world! They give this movie NC-17 and at the same time they give brutal Saw only R. Isn't this ridiculously beyond belief? And they give totally innocent "Mrs Henderson Presents" R!!! How's that?
At the same time look at French rating: Atame! in France has U rating (valid for all audiences) and Saw III - 18 (that is equivalent to porn movies). That's what I call totally logical rating, but MPAA system is a total joke and can't be taken seriously by any sane viewer.

reply