Actually, I think Uma did an excellent job, considering that her role didn't have much screen time. When it comes to June, and the fact we're looking at the story from most of the point of view of Anais Nin, with Uma's performance as June, it leaves us being drawn to the character with the small amount of time that Anais had with her. When it comes to June as a character, we have to take something into account: we are looking at her from both Henry and Anais' points of view. So, if they see her the way she is portrayed in the film as empathic and phony, it's because that's how both Miller and Nin see her. We do not ever get her point of view on things and we never will, because of the following (from WIkipedia):
Although she expressed a desire to write an autobiography, she never wrote anything other than letters.
And that's backed up by her statement in the film when she talks to Anais after seeing her again at the party ("Sorry I couldn't keep in touch. I thought of you every day. But you know me with writing, I have a terrible time. I don't have the gift like you and Henry.") So, we're stuck with the point of view by a man who loved her as much as he hated her and a woman who barely got much time to spend with her.
When it comes to what we are told by the real Henry Miller and Anais Nin are strictly how they see her.
In the film, there's a scene where Henry explains to June about the character in "Tropic of Cancer" that is based on her and she points out that he "makes everything ugly" because "beauty is a joke" to him. Anais only spent a small amount of time with June, so obviously she would be naive about who June was (as June in the film pointed out, Anais' writing of her seemed poetic and that she was expecting "something more real"). Basically, other than what Henry and Anais written about her, we really do not know much about June, let alone how much is true and how much is not. If June was as emphatic and phony as she was portrayed by Henry Miller and Anais Nin, then why did they bother to continue to use her as a literary influence? In fact, Henry continued to send money to her through friends after they divorced. So, there had to be something more about her than what we've been told. Too bad we'll never know.
But this one's eating my popcorn!
reply
share