MovieChat Forums > Ghost (1990) Discussion > I now realise, Patrick Swayze was miscas...

I now realise, Patrick Swayze was miscast


I used to think he was perfect as a child but now I don't think so.

I heard about a lot of more serious actors passing on this role, including Tom Cruise. Now I wonder what a better actor could have brought to this role?

Firstly the positive. Patrick sells the romance and the physicality of being an attractive partner. He also seems like the guy who'd say Ditto.

His chemistry with Demi and Whoopie are on point.

That's the positive, now the negative.

His age is a bit of an issue with his partner and best friend being 20 somethings, while he looks close to 40 in some shots. I'm left to wonder why he hangs out with people much younger and how young were they when he met them?

A lot of this movie requires him to look shocked. Unfortunately, Patrick's eyes aren't up to the job. They convey a deer in the headlights, not the intensity required for someone who is dealing with the shock of being a ghost and dealing with the betrayal by his friend.

The only time I was like "you're nailing the emotional intensity" was when we see him in bed waking up and discovering Molly is the angel statue, then the light appearing. He sold it. He looks engaged. He's in despair. He knows he's dead. But elsewhere he left me wanting.

I would love to have seen Tom Cruise in this role.

A young Tom Cruise opposite a young Demi would have been very interesting. His youth would have added more to the tragedy of his death. The whole "young love" dynamic.

Plus Tom would be better at selling the New York banker vibe.




reply

"I'm left to wonder why he hangs out with people much younger and how young were they when he met them?"

In olden times (1990-ish and before) people weren't obsessed, like they are today, with silly-named "generations". They didn't keep exclusively to tribes of others their own age. Many very young people, even teenagers, looked forward to being accepted into the grownup world, and enjoyed hanging out with somewhat older men and women. There was no knee-jerk social stigma about it, as there is today. In contrast to the current attitude, it was considered a positive thing. It was a more rational, more mature time.

reply

I'm a massive Swayze fan and this is certainly one of his better movies, but I wouldn't disagree with this. This movie certainly would have been stronger with Tom Cruise. Swayze wasn't the best actor. But he always gave 110 percent. It's part of his charm.

reply

His good looks and charm carried him far that's for sure.

reply

I never got that he was age inappropriate for Demi Moore, he was late 30´s, she was late 20´s. That´s not that uncommon and it has never been a negative for me.

reply

In 1990, Tony Goldwyn was 30, and Demi Moore was 28/29. Patrick Swayze was 38.

The ten years age gap between Demi and Patrick is very normal I feel. My parents are also ten years apart.

As for Carl, it doesn’t seem odd that he’d be friends with someone 8 years younger.

reply

Demi seemed much younger.

reply

My parents were also 10 years apart, but in the movies, the actors ages are not the character ages.

reply

I don't think you're wrong, but I like Swayze in this. He brings a lot of levity to a role that a more intense actor wouldn't have pulled off - and I think the movie needs that. I wouldn't want it to be darker than it is. Swayze also manages to come off as extremely likeable even when he's messing with the other characters as a ghost, which I find endearing in a way I don't think someone like Cruise could have managed.

reply

He's very likeable but so was Bill Cosby. Not a great serious actor however.

reply

Definitely not, but I kind of like that about this movie. Whenever it leans toward serious, Swayze brings it back into a lighter, more humorous place. For me, that's what makes this movie work - it's balanced.

reply

This

reply

You are right, Swayze was perfect.

reply

Cheers.

reply

Swayze was perfect for ‘Road House’ & ‘Dirty Dancing’ - but a terrible choice for roles needing gravitas!

Ghost was a neat idea, with some great ‘made for trailer’ scenes, such as Demi’s ‘tears’ - and of course a wonderful musical choice with ‘Unchained Melody’ - but Swayze was as wooden as a tree trunk! *

reply