MovieChat Forums > Stepfather II (1989) Discussion > Film is offensive to the psychiatrist pr...

Film is offensive to the psychiatrist profession


If I were a psychologist or psychiatrist, I would find this film as well as the others in the series highly offensive. In the films, psychiatrists were portrayed as either complete morons, or at least as not even at the same level of intelligence as mental patients!

In the first film, the psychiatrist that Stephanie consulted wanted to talk to the Stepfather to discuss her problems. But instead of going through the proper channels, he posed as someone wanting to buy a house from the real estate firm where the Stepfather worked and so needlessly got murdered.

At the beginning of this film, the psychiatrist that examined the Stepfather had a most annoyingly patronizing attitude. He went to the extreme to show how understanding and “caring” he was. That black dude clearly believed himself to be superior and smart, but actually the Stepfather had completely outwitted him. The psychiatrist had a smug look on his face as he turned his back to the Stepfather to drop down notes and immediately received a drill through the neck. So we see a mental patient actually outwitting and even manipulating the one who was supposed to cure him!

Worst of all, later the same escaped mental patient was even able to pose as a psychiatrist specializing in “family guidance” and nobody noticed anything wrong or unusual. In the film we even see the Stepfather giving a therapy session for a group of women. I shudder to think what kind of “advices” this “self-taught” psychiatrist had given to those women!! But I guess most of those women were probably quite crazy anyway – like the one who talked about making “songs” for her husband as she was doing something naughty.

reply

It was offensive to mail carriers as well.



------

Wait a minute... who am I here?

reply

Although I don't know that the psychiatrist/psychologist portrayals in either film were realistic, or the escape from the institution, it's not that unusual for mental patients to be smarter than their doctors, and even to manipulate them to a degree. I've known people who are smarter than their therapists, although the outcome is usually just not getting helped much.

And it's not much of a stretch to believe that a criminal psychopath who had outwitted police for a long while could outwit a couple of doctors.

reply

Who cares, it's a slasher flick

reply

Who cares, it's a slasher flick


HOLLA! 👍

-------------------------------------------
This post was most likely edited due to lameness.

reply

I don't know that I would get too offended by the portrayal of anything in a low-rent (but nevertheless enjoyable) slasher sequel like this.

reply

I know this thread is old but I did not think that the black psychiatrist was being smug at all. My take on it was that he was genuinely empathetic towards the Stepfather. It was almost as if he felt sorry for him.

reply

I found it odd that Jerry/Gene called himself a psychiatrist in Part 2.
A psychiatrist could (and likely would!) be called upon to prescribe medication.
Jerry would have been unable to do that.

He should have merely called himself a family counselor or even psychologist.

How exactly was he being paid? Most people have insurance, and again, would reveal Jerry as a fraud.

These films are not meant to be taken too seriously I know, and they are fun, but some of the plot holes are glaring.



I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus.
Didn't he discover America?
Penfold, shush.

reply