MovieChat Forums > Steel Magnolias (1989) Discussion > I'm not diabetic... how realistic was th...

I'm not diabetic... how realistic was the diabetic attack scene?


I'm not diabetic...but I am curious about how realistic was the diabetic attack scene in the hair salon? I remember when the movie came out people making fun of that scene where she freaks out and yells at everybody but it kinda scared me to be honest.

Anyone with diabetes care to comment on what it's like to have an attack like that?

Character is what you are in the dark.

reply

I don't have diabetes myself, but my now ex-boyfriend did have diabetes. I'd say the scene in the beauty parlor is fairly accurate to what a real diabetic attack is like.

I witnessed an attack when my boyfriend's sugars dropped to low levels, and it was kind of like he was drunk. He was yelling words that didn't make much sense, and he was shaking badly. It was kind of scary for me, since I had never seen it happen before. I had to run and get a can of soda and pour it into his mouth to get the levels back up to normal.

reply

But the thing that doesn't make sense is that shelby has been a diabetic all her life and she recognizes the signs of a hypoglycemic attack really quickly. It 's not reallistic that she doesn't do anything about it right away, even if she wasn't 100% sure it was an attack. She should have drunk something from the moment she felt something even if it was to prevent a real attack of rule out a diabetic attack

- "is this the secret headquarters of the gestapo?"
- "It was"

reply

I had asked a friend of mine who was a juvenile diabetic if that scene was realistic, and she said "Absolutely".
As for the scene when she does have it, the only reason I can give for Shelby not doing anything about the attack is to show the viewer what was wrong with her so that it would explain more in the film later on.

reply

I'm a diabetic - type 2, so my issues aren't as bad, but I have experienced dangerous lows, and you do start to shake, and speak weirdly, and when your sugar starts to rebound (after intaking some fast acting sugar) you can be mean and combative because your brain is in chaos. It's weird. I felt like I was locked in my body watching a movie of this happening.

I can feel myself going low, except for when I'm sick or stressed out. I had surgery 5 weeks ago, and not long after, my blood sugar dropped low one day and I didn't notice until it was in the low 50's and I got the shakes. I had post-surgery pain, and the early symptoms went unnoticed.

Also, those with Type 1, especially those with the complications she appeared to have, get to a point where their body gets used to lows and they don't feel them until it's too late. My dad (also diabetic) wakes up when he goes low overnight but Type 1's have a term called "dead in bed". That's when they get a low overnight and don't feel it, and never wake up.

My guess is she was stressed out over the wedding and her pre-marital issues, and didn't notice the symptoms, or her body had burned out and she wouldn't have noticed the symptoms at all no matter what the situation.

reply

My grandma was a diabetic, and I watched her have an attack similar to Shelby's.
I walked in on her to visit her, and she was sitting in her chair looking furious & somehow 'gray' in her face.
She looked up at me like something out of a horror film, and started to speak. But she made no sense at all! I'd never seen her have a 'diabetic attack' before, but I instantly knew what was wrong.

I poured her some ginger ale kept for her occasional tummy troubles. She instantly refused to drink it, just like Shelby did in the film.

Finally, she sipped it a few times. Not a minute later, she looks uo at me, all smiles, and says "Oh hi! When did you get here?"
She had NO memory of what had just happened! So I do believe Shelby's attack was realistic.
Plus, one needs to remember that Shelby was more than just the *standard* diabetic.
She had severe complications, such as circulatory problems. M'Lynn mentions this twice, once at the beauty parlor when she says Shelby should quit working after she marries to be kinder to her body.
That's why the specialists said she shouldn't have a baby, her circulatory system was already compromised. But having Jack Jr. blew out her kidney completely.




"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

Her attack was exactly the way you look with very sudden, low blood sugar, didn't m'lynn say it was too much insulin? I've felt that way during episodes and you sweat, shake, get dizzy and nauseous. I never lost consciousness or lashed out but yes you look like that and afterwards, after drinking Gatorade you feel better but bad, like you've run a marathon, just wiped out.

reply

I've seen people, as you're giving them the sugar, go, "You rat bastard! Get out of my face ......... oh. I'm so sorry." The personality change is really startling if you've never seen it. As for the onset, it can be scary fast, especially for a "brittle" diabetic like Shelby. Type 1 diabetics are always having to be very careful about their insulin and blood sugar levels because they can change suddenly and drastically.

Innsmouth Free Press http://www.innsmouthfreepress.com

reply

I'm a diabetic and it's type 2 and so is my fiance and he also has type 2. In my experience, I have been under so much stress, that I have mistaken my shaking for just nerves, but in reality very low blood sugar. I remember when my daughter was 1 year old, and I was 4 months pregnant with my son, I wasn't feeling well and took a nap. My then husband was on his way to see my dying mother in law. I got a phone call and was shaking like crazy and was sweating. I thought I had a fever. I took my temperature and it was normal. I then tested my blood sugar, and it was down to 30 I knocked on my neighbor's door and she gave me a glass of sugar water, and I don't remember anything else. My fiance and I are brittle diabetics, so for us it isn't easy even with having an endocrinologist managing our blood sugar levels. A few times, my fiance's blood sugar was so low, I had to call an ambulance, and his personality changed completely until he was stabilized. In fact, he doesn't remember anything about these times either. It is very scary to experience your heart beating so strong that you feel it ad so scary to witness someoe going through it as well.

reply

These type 2's speaking on the issues of Type 1's is like a prostate or breast cancer patient trying compare their issues with one who has pancreatic cancer.

Here's some free medical advice and a cure for your "condition," lose weight. Boom. There. Your insulin resistance is gone. No more swallowing two Metformin a day and funding can now concentrate on the autoimmune disease of Type 1.

reply

Are you referring to my answer? If so, I will respond back

reply

I'm referring to all of them. You can respond if you want.

reply

First of all, I have had stage 4 kidney disease for 8 years, so i can't take metformin. I was very very thin when i was diagnosed with diabetes. My husband is at the right weight for his body, but is not allowed to take metformin , due to past kidney problems. Losing weight, is not always the way to control brittle diabetes.

reply

Unless you're 70 years old, you were not very thin when you were diagnosed. Type 2 afflicts two types of people - overweight and/or elderly. My guess is your "brittle" diabetes (which, if it actually exists, is a Type 1 condition) is difficult to control because YOU do a poor job regulated your BG levels. Ask your doctor if losing weight will help your Type 2 diabetes.

reply

I was 20 years old and was 100 pounds when I was diagnosed. Are you an endocrinologist? For your information, my endocrinologist is having difficulty with how much insulin to give me, and he refers to me and my husband as brittle diabetics.

reply

If you were 100 lbs and 20 years old at diagnosis, you DEFINITELY sound like a textbook type 1 (aka Juvenile Diabetes). Are you sure you didn't mix the two up? And I assume you're using a pump, syringes, or pens?

reply

I was able to control my diabetes with my diet and didn't need any insulin, until I turned 30 was a lot heavier and had gestational diabetes. I then needed insulin. I then had another baby 18 months later , still heavy, and needed insulin. After my second child was born, I was told that due to my weight and I was now 32, I had Type 2 diabetes and they had me take metformin and insulin. In 2008, I was diagnosed with stage 4 kidney disease, and in 2013, i was diagnosed with diabetic retinopathy. ( sorry, I don't know how to spell it). I used to get laser treatments for the eye that got affected, but now i can't any longer. I am only able to get treated by injections, or at the last resort surgery. I only found out by eye condition when my my no husband went to the doctor. We are both diabetics and had the same doctor. She mentioned to him that he should get his eyes checked due to his diabetes. I asked if I should go as well. She said " I guess so", even though she knew that I was diagnosed much earlier than he was. In fact no doctor ever told me about the dangers of diabetes, such as damage to my eyes or kidneys. I was aware of amputations, and kidney failure, but my doctors never explained to me anything about complications. I now take insulin . I am doing my best to keep things under control. Right now, my kidney doctor says that my kidney disease is under control and he doesn't see the need for me to receive dialysis or a new kidney in the near future. I do my best to stay positive. God bless.

reply