Overlong and tedious


Jean-Jacques Beineix has made several excellent films ('Diva,' 'Mortel Tranfert'), but 'Roselyne' is a misdirected (literally) dud. Beineix has problems reining himself in as a director. He has a tendency to think every frame he shoots should be included in the finished product (see the relentlessly boring, 140-minute 'The Moon in the Gutter'). Producers have a hard time convincing him that everything he shoots is not necessarily golden. The theatrical release of his successful 'Betty Blue' was an already long 120 minutes; Beineix's cut is an intolerable 185 minutes.

In 'Roselyne and the Lions,' Beineix again shows us his lack of discipline. This is a film basically about two young people who become lion tamers, first in their home town and then progressively in the big time in Berlin. If you like to watch giant lions and tigers being trained ad nauseum, you might even enjoy it.

There are some prints of this film that go on for 180 minutes. The version I saw was about 150 minutes, and even that was an hour too long. It didn't make sense, because the storyline is weak and so are the characters. During the entire first hour of the film, nothing really happens. The director apparently thought he was working on an epic, and he was partly right: it's an epic bore.

'Roselyne' is also, unfortunately, badly dated. It was made in 1989. Not many people are interested anymore in how lions are tamed with whips and chairs.

reply

I like the film, I watched the 3h version (2h55m) and was not bored at all. It's a very nostalgic film in my opinion and reminds me of Fellini a bit.

Yes, the story is very simple, so are che characters but I "got" the epic feeling the director created.

Only thing that was a downer was how often it was mentioned that "the lions are in heat". After hearing that for at least 10 times in short time periods it just got ridiculous but my heart is with the film.

_
SEUL CONTRE TOUS
www.myspace.com/anzycpethian
www.pbase.com/anzycpethian

reply

[deleted]

Actually Diva is dated and overrated, more style than substance. By the time Beineix made the underwhelming and ridiculous Mortal Transfer he lost his touch. However, Roselyne and the Lions is a wonderful and impressive little gem, like IP5.

reply

Haven't seen Diva in a long while, but I remember it being pretty suspenseful at times and very stylish.

I loved Betty Blue, so I just rented RatL and IP5 from the library. I plan to watch them in the next few days, so your comment is encouraging...

reply

I just rented RatL and IP5 from the library. I plan to watch them in the next few days


Old post alert, but what did you think of them?

reply