I don't tear up when I watch this series, but I do marvel at its continuing influence on the other series that have followed it. I am, however, a little concerned at the reception of the series, especially nowadays, some 30 years after this groundbreaking, though heavily derivative story debuted.
The series clearly owes a tremendous debt to Wolfgang Peterson's 'Das Boot' (1981) and similar films depicting a conflict from 'the other side', and yet we are not shown a group of 'ordinary, everyday guys' fighting a war to which they might feel conflicted, yet still feel committed; we are shown instead a unit of ill-tempered, maladjusted commandoes who, for the most part, comport themselves as undisciplined sociopathic killers, with little regard or compassion for supposedly neutral civilians; one member has little problem with killing children and policemen if it protects his mission, while another decides to instigate a (possibly) alcohol-fuelled rampage rather than a mere diversion (what he was ordered to do), which escalates into a fracas claiming hundreds of civilian lives. Is the Earth Federation solely to be blamed for this carnage? The commandoes seem to have been immunized, since they clearly specialize in 'shock and awe' tactics that have no place in a heavy civilian population, and thus their infiltration operation on Side 6 seems ill-conceived and doomed from the start. The only truly bad person in the Zeon forces appears to be the Commander, who is simply a 2-dimensional cartoon villain lifted from the original series, and a too-easy object of hatred. This man murders his own commanding officer so he can launch a nuclear strike on a supposedly neutral space colony. Detractors of the series often call it 'fascist' and 'sadistic', but I feel the ideas watchers should be most careful with are those echoing the conflicted views many Japanese hold to this day, over their country's role in the Second World War.
reply
share