regretted?


i read in richard carpenter's IMDB bio that he regretted being part of The Karen Carpenter Story. does anyone know why?

reply

I think because it just sucked. It was a cheap made for TV thing. Very poorly done, poorly acted in my opinion.


"In the midst of life we are in death"-Stand by me

reply

i saw it last week & i liked it. i do LOVE 70s and 80s television tho. i liked that girl that played Karen Carpenter.

reply

[deleted]

It's only hearsay so I can't say for sure it's accurate, but I knew a girl who appeared as an extra in this movie. She said that Richard was on the set and she had talked to him, and he said his involvement was much less than he had been promised and much less than the producers wanted viewers to think--basically they just wanted his name on it to give it some credibility but they gave him no say in anything. He wasn't at all happy with the final product, because they invented entire scenes for dramatic effect and he felt Karen was portrayed as a weak victim, which was not who she was. (Again, this is hearsay, I don't know for sure that Richard said any of that--someone just told me he did.)

There was some unfortunate casting for sure; Cynthia Gibb was completely unbelievable as Karen. Gibb was always more of a soap opera actress--not to say there's anything wrong with soap opera actresses, it's just that a completely different acting style is required to carry a film (even a made for TV film) and Gibb didn't appear to be up to the challenge. She made Karen look a bit like a cartoon character instead of the warm, sensitive, talented young lady who was loved by so many.

One thing they did right was to use tapes of Karen singing, rather than have Gibb try to imitate the inimitable Karen Carpenter's lovely, unique and very distinctive voice.

On the whole, it's good that a movie was made in an attempt to honor and remember someone so special and gifted. It's just a shame they didn't spend a little more money to do a better job of it, and more input from her brother would surely have helped.

reply

Karen Carpenter's voice is my all time favorite. I just cannot believe how wonderful it is and how that smooth contralto voice can get into your head. I love what KD Lang said about her voice "It is like rich chocolate."

reply

Richard Carpenter has had accusing fingers pointed at him since Karens' death, along the lines of whether he forced Karen to stay slim or not. A lot of people say that Richard was the cause behind Karens eating disorders, and thus Richard has been shown in a dodgy light ever since.

I reckon he regretted making this movie because it dragged up the past where he is seen in a bad light; that, and it's not the greatest TV movie ever.

It's a shame because I love the Carpenters.

reply

There's absolutely nothing in Ray Coleman's published biography of the Carpenters to indicate that Richard had a role in Karen's obsessive dieting. In fact, during the duo's early years, Karen maintained a healthy weight and appearance. It wasn't until the mid-70s that she appeared to develop anorexia. The reasons for her disorder remain unclear, but both siblings appeared to exhibit perfectionist tendencies, and such personality types may be susceptible to anorexia.

reply

Where can one read "Ray Coleman's published biography"?

reply

Coleman's biography of the Carpenters has been out of print for a number of years now. You should be able to find a second-hand copy at used book stores or over the internet. Try Amazon. There are multiple listings currently for used copies, as well as exorbitantly priced "new" copies. If you're just looking to read rather than buy, see if it's available at your local library. If it's not there, you can probably get it through inter-library loan.

reply

I agree Cynthia wasn't very good in this and the whole thing did have a cheap look to it. I wish they would do a movie that is more accurate and find an actress that really looks and sound slike Karen.

reply

I realize this thread is very old, but I am watching this film on Encore as I type this.

It's only hearsay so I can't say for sure it's accurate


dragongrrrllll - From the press that I remember when this film came out your friend sounds pretty accurate. Richard wasn't happy with the production, it was not up to his exacting standards (by a long shot).

I am grateful that he allowed them to use their actual tracks in the film, as there is little video of The (actual) Carpenters available. Richard is very protective of their recorded work and does not allow it to be used very often.

The acting and script may be faulty, but it is still a passable tribute to one of my lifetime's best vocalists.

reply

I see that Richard even directed some of it which seems quite surprising. After all, Joe Sargent was one of the most successful television directors of his generation, so it makes me wonder where exactly Richard was calling "action" and "cut".

reply