Why isn't Indiana Jones immortal?


Both of them drank from the Holy Grail, which gives you everlasting life. Henry Jones was about to die if it weren't for drinking from the Holy Grail and healing his wounds. So technically, shouldn't he have died as soon as he set foot outside the Temple?

The Knight said you can't leave the Temple. But he wasn't too clear if that meant to be immortal you also had to stay in the temple, or that you merely weren't allowed to take the Grail out of there.

reply

The Grail Knight explains it perfectly to Indy, after he wisely chooses the correct Grail:

"The Grail cannot pass beyond the Great Seal. That is the boundary, and the price of immortality."

I take that to mean that while people wishing to be healed can come to that temple and drink from the Grail itself (whether or not the Final Challenge of traps was reset or not) they cannot take it with them or the whole place will collapse, as we started to see when Elsa selfishly took it and walked across the Great Seal. It's a good limitation imposed by God on what would otherwise be coveted by everyone, but since you'd have to keep drinking from the Grail to achieve immortality, as the Knight did as an example, you'd be stuck in that place forever and couldn't leave. More limitations.

It seems the only people God wants being immortal is devout Christian worshippers, like the Knight. In other words, people who don't mind an extremely limited lifestyle.

reply


The Grail Knight explains it perfectly to Indy, after he wisely chooses the correct Grail:
"The Grail cannot pass beyond the Great Seal. That is the boundary, and the price of immortality."


Exactly. Odd how so many people totally miss that and think anyone who passes the seal after drinking from the Grail will still be immortal. That at least was clearly explained.


It's a good limitation imposed by God on what would otherwise be coveted by everyone, but since you'd have to keep drinking from the Grail to achieve immortality, as the Knight did as an example, ...


Nitpicking, but I don't think it was determined that you would have to necessarily *keep* drinking from the Grail to stay alive. I mean, perhaps you'd need some kind of food and water (and I didn't see a privy in that cave...) to otherwise stay alive, but the way it seemed to me was that once you drank from the Grail, you'd live forever as long as you didn't pass the seal, whether or not you drank any more from the Grail.

I guess there could be three options about the Grail that wasn't specifically addressed other than the "no passing the great seal" warning:

1) You drink from the Grail and keep drinking from the Grail in order to stay alive.
2) You drink from the Grail and you stay alive as long as you otherwise eat food and drink any water even if it's not from the Grail.
3) You drink from the Grail and you stay alive even if you drink or eat nothing else for eternity.





reply

It's weird that the Grail heals his wounds but does not turn him young. Aging is a wound, it just happens over a longer period of time.

The Grail was not allowed to go past the seal, the people went back and forth over it and nothing happened. Apparently The Grail must be used periodically to keep someone from dying even if it does not stop them from aging.

reply


The grail heals but doesn't de-age. That's why the knight looks as old as he does (as did his brother who made it out of the desert after 150 years and still died of "extreme old age")



... three Knights of the First Crusade. Three brothers, to be exact ... Two of these brothers walked out of the desert one hundred and fifty years after having found the Grail and began the long journey back to France.

But only one of them made it. And before dying of extreme old age, he supposedly imparted his tale to a -- to a Franciscan friar, I think.


So while I agree aging can be viewed as a "wound," apparently the Grail disagrees.

reply

He is immortal. Thats why he survived the nuclear blast in the fridge

reply