MovieChat Forums > For All Mankind (1989) Discussion > Horrible science question

Horrible science question


When they show the footage of the astronaut outside the capsule while orbiting earth - he said he was going 25K miles per hour. I don't get how that works. With no gravity there is no wind??? How does he just float while going that fast.

Told you it was stupid.

Also great footage. I love that once we left the earth it was really the only thing that was cool to look at from space.


Leave the gun. Take the cannoli.

reply

At their altitudes, there isn't enough of anything like air to push back on them as they fly around at high speeds, because earth's gravity isn't strong enough. When you feel air pushing on your hands in a car, that's newton's third law. In space there simply aren't enough particles of anything to push back on you as you move forward.

reply

Thank you so much!!!

Leave the gun. Take the cannoli.

reply

Hence the Hammer and Feather test they show in the film.

reply

and that was SO cool! Because if they showed it on tv at the time, I was in the first three or four years of school and didn't think on that level of science... so it wouldn't have made an impression.

reply

Low orbit is close enough to the earth to experience almost the same full force of gravity we do. But the spacewalking astronaut doesn't "feel" gravity because he's literally falling continuously around the earth, never hitting it. ("Free fall" is the term").

His spacecraft is also falling. So is his umbilical cord and fellow astronauts. They all fall together at the same speed so there's no reason for any of it to move with respect to anything else. They seem weightless.

Look up Isaac Newton. He shows how firing a cannon with faster and faster muzzle speeds would eventually allow a ball, moving fast enough, to literally fall all the way around the earth without hitting it. Although this is impractical - we use rockets, not cannons - Newton's original explanation of how an orbit works is still the best one around, centuries later.

reply


I don't remember the science of it, but there is this old fifties era sci-fi movie that explained it well. The movie can be found on YouTube and is called "Destination Moon". Robert Heinlein was the technical advisor on that movie.

























If you love and support Michael Jackson 100%, copy & paste this into your signature. We love MJ!

reply

Imagine the unknown being the first man in space to open the door. It goes against all instincts. In the US we don't hear much about the first man who did that probably because it was a Russian.

reply

The first man to walk in space was a Soviet. I think his name was Aleksei Leonov.






"Joey, have you ever been in a Turkish prison?"

reply