MovieChat Forums > Alien Nation (1989) Discussion > If the premise of this series actually h...

If the premise of this series actually happened...


Could you see yourself befriending the Newcomers? I could because from the show, most of them--the obvious exceptions were the Newcomer criminals Matt and George went after on the show--were decent enough, the only real jerks on the show were those Purist fools.

Take for example George's son Buck. He was mildly racist but that seemed to be only in reaction to humans' general attitude towards the Newcomers. Either that or those punks he hung around with who put all that stuff about, "Your Dad sold out to the Terts." In his head. As evidenced by his close friendship with his human English teacher who taught him to read Madame Bovary and Catcher in the Rye, deep down he liked humans and was a decent person, he just hid that with his pig-headed surface.

Another example: In the (Caan/Patinkin) movie, Sykes' cop adversaries tease George about not coming down in the sand, and Sykes remarks how much surfing would they do next to a sea of hydrochloric acid? That's true. We wouldn't want the Newcomers laughing at us for being afraid of battery acid, why should we laugh at them for being afraid of sea water?

I loved this show as a kid, have the Series DVD, and I will always refer to it as underrated, not because it wasn't popular which I know it was, but because it only lasted one season. Should have ran for at least four.

reply

I also loved this series and also have the DVD (am watching it now).

I just don't see the "Human Race" being so accepting as the show portrays. look at our history and then imagine adding the Newcomers to the mix. I just don't see a good outcome. Us humans like to think we are number one.

reply

Yea, and in a way it did happen hundreds of years ago, the indians had to deal with euopeans coming over to their territory.

reply

That's true but people learn and grow. Over a hundred years ago americans steamrolled across the country but today more people are willing to stand up for equality for everyone. It's not something everyone will jump on board for but I can see it happening the same way.

reply

[deleted]

"Over a hundred years ago americans steamrolled across the country but today more people are willing to stand up for equality for everyone."

Yeah, tell that to all your Iranian-American Muslim friends and see if they're polite enough NOT to laugh in your face.

(Because I SAID so, that's why!)

reply

101WaysToBeLazy never said intolerance doesn't exist nowadays. However, Americans are more tolerant now than they were a hundred years ago. A hundred years from now, we will (hopefully) be more tolerant then than we are today.

As for if aliens actually landed and had to live among us, sad to say, but I think they'd be treated worse than what the show has shown. Humans in general are intolerant of differences that have been around for hundreds of years. Wherever aliens landed, I think it'd take them a lot longer to get to the point where they are on the show than it did on the show.

-
Don't give CPR to a Tok'ra.

reply

You're absolutely correct - the mistake I made was reading "today MORE PEOPLE ARE willing to stand up..." as "today PEOPLE ARE MORE willing to stand up..." (i.e., I thought it said that every person is more tolerant, rather than more people are tolerant.) Oops! I gotta quit speedreading...

[Straining at gnats & swallowing camels is a required course for lawyers -- and bloggers]

reply

Yeah, just look at the "interview" segements in District 9... pretty accurate, imo, what you would see as a response, almost "hey cool, got no problem with it, just NIMBY! Don't care as long as it doesn't affect my own personal day to day life!"

In other words, there's plenty of individual persons who are pretty cool, smart, decent, open-minded, giving, understand, etc.

But people are idiots.


- - -

Chipping away at a mountain of pop culture trivia,
Darren Dirt.

reply