A plot hole


I didn't like the story, it was too poor, and though Hyams tried to hide it by unnecessary long sequences of car chases he couldn't make audience really involved in the story. The authors had no success in making us wonder either who did it or why did he do it, though both questions appear in the movie.

And not only the story didn't contain much, but it contained an important plot hole.

*** SPOILER ***

When Lawrence was hit by a car, it appeared to be a car of his companion who was afraid that, if caught and interrogated, Lawrence might confess and send them all to jail. So, the plot suggests that Lawrence was killed by intention.

However, we can see that Lawrence was running through several blocks sometimes changing his direction. Even if the killer tried to follow him, he couldn't have predicted where would Lawrence go. And he hit him in the moment when Lawrence appeared from the small street hidden by big buildings, so there is no chance that a driver could have seen him more than a second before. How could he know that Lawrence would appear at this point, and that moment? Not to forget that Lawrence was losing power, his last few meters were much slower, and he simply wasn't able to run across the street any more. Nothing that the driver/killer could have known. Unfortunately, the story develops as if this was a crucial point, a planned execution, and by finding who owned the car the investigators managed to complete the puzzle and solve the case.

Completely implausible and ridiculous. Even if for Hollywood action movie, this is too much.

reply

what about after the guy doesn't shoot mark harmon when he walks up to him--the asian cop just picks up a phone & yells 'we need some help in here!!!'---but he didn't dial a number.



Where there's smoke, there's barbecue!

reply

A plot hole A plot hole A plot hole A plot hole a butt hole found A plot hole

"I fought your kind in the great war and we kicked the living *beep* out of you"

reply

I love how good guys with handguns always win over bad guys with submachine guns.

reply

There's a lot more than one plot hole. It is obvious Harmon's character has only been out of the Army for 2 years. No one makes detective at SFPD in 2 years, and working homicide?

Why is SFPD investigating a homicide on an Army base? That is strictly CID jurisdiction.If they asked SFPD for assistance the PD still wouldn't be the lead agency in the investigation, CID would be. No way would a hot shot PD detective walk in and tell the CID people that "I don't want you touching anything, my people will..?
In the real world Harmon's character would be paired with a CID agent.

The Army would never permit a LtCol. provost marshal to become actively involved in a criminal investigation. PMs are administrators, not field investigators.

PS- I was in the Army 8 years and a cop for 32.

reply

Thanks for this information. I don't live in USA (never been there either) and - though I also wondered about jurisdiction - having just a little knowledge about it (mostly from movies, and we can see how reliable sources they are) I left others better informed to comment it.

reply

When Lawrence was hit by a car ...
How many times in countless movies do you see characters hit by vehicles which come out of nowhere, making no sound until the point of impact? IRL unlikely to happen, I think its part of those reliable devices that we see "only in the movies".🐭

reply

When he appeared in the middle of the street it is no wonder he was hit by A car, but not by THE car that did it. He could have been hit by a retired ornithologist, a nun, a drug dealer or a babysitter, he wasn't hit because he was Lawrence but because he was a person who appeared out of nowhere in front of a running car. Would the police investigate with same enthusiasm to check if this was an execution in some monastic orders conflict, or if Lawrence was maybe investigating some falsified ornithology theories?

reply