MovieChat Forums > Lady in White (1988) Discussion > So who was taking her? (spoilers)

So who was taking her? (spoilers)


S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S


I know in the film, that Phil is the man, but Phil wasn't a ghost. So who always took her to the cliff?

reply

Becase Phil Was still alive....

reply

I don't think anyone was really taking Melissa to the cliff. Her spirit couldn't rest until the killer was caught/revealed, so her ghost just kept re-enacting her murder and disposal off the cliff. I hope that makes sense.

reply

It was a re-enactment. No one else needed to be "seen" other than the ghost. So Phil being still alive wouldn't change the fact that it was him who killed her.

reply