MovieChat Forums > Gor Discussion > First 3 books

First 3 books


Very sad how they turned a couple of fantastic books into a travesty of a movie. The movies did not do these books justice. Terrible acting, awful screenplay, and inferior directing with not-so-special effects. Sesame Street caliber. Very disappointing ..... this movie could've, and SHOULD'VE, been so much better.

The first book was the best. The unknowing hero (Tarl) is plucked from earth to a similar planet on the other side of the sun, and trained be a great warrior. He encounters various fantastic creatures, an evil ruler, beautiful scantily clad women, and a civilization that considers him an outlaw since he "belongs" to no city. The planet is run by the powerful yet mysterious Priest-Kings, who set a limit on advancement and keep the world in a quasi-medieval age. They live up in a huge mountain that is seemingly impossible to breach. No one has seen them, although many have witnessed their fury when a rule is broken.

The first 3 books are in my collection. That's all I wanted out of the 20-something books by John Norman. After the 3rd, where Tarl goes up the mountain to defiantly confront the Priest-Kings, there really didn't need to be more.

The series began to drop off considerably after that. Women were mostly slaves throughout the series of books. In the 2nd book one of the main female characters was leader of a city, while a few others in the first 5 were aggressive and headstrong. They weren't all submissive all of the time, which provided a few well-timed surprises. The only thing that bored me was Norman's endless descriptions of Gor's culture. This slowed the pace that kept me interested, so I just bypassed those parts when I ran into them. I'm sure a few nerds chose to get involved in the entire culture, similar to many in the Star Trek universe who got into speaking Klingon.

I read up to book 5 and wasn't too impressed with the 4th and 5th. The stories became repetitive with Tarl being captured (again!) and Norman got really hardcore with the female slave subject. Just too over the top in my opinion. The rest of the series is worthless after the 1st 3, I wouldn't take any of the later books even if someone offered them for free.

I absolutely LOATHE remakes, but if EVER a movie or series of movies needed to be remade, it's these. No list of big names needed, I'd be happy with all unknowns if they did it right. With the special effects of today, we could witness a wonderful story brought to the big screen (the right way!), and the majestic Tarns in glorious flight.

reply

[deleted]

Neven read the books, but I'm told they're better. I'd be fine with a reboot movie or movies based on the earlier ones.


For DEMONIC TOYS and updates on Full Moon Films:
www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

I didn't much like the first one "Tarnsman of Gor" on account that it was too focused on being the 'origin story', but the next five in the the series are all outstanding. You say everything after "Priest Kings of Gor" (#3) was lousy, but the fourth one "Nomads of Gor" is easily the magnum opus of the series. "Assassins of Gor" (#5) is very good as well and "Raiders of Gor" (#6) is exceptional.

It wasn't until "Captive of Gor" (#7) that the series went downhill for good. I read 'em all up to approximately #20 and it never returned to the greatness of the first six books.

reply

Yep, Nomads was a really good one. I can't remember 6 or 7, so that's probably when it started to go downhill for me. Read quite a few of the others, but they just became misogynist bore fests.

reply

I highly recommend "Assassins of Gor" (#5) and "Raiders of Gor" (#6). The latter in particular is exceptional, once you get past the first 100 pages (only because the writer goes into superfluous detail on various things; you know what I mean). With "Captive of Gor" the series definitely became a bore fest, as you call it, with an occasional shining moment but too much redundant or dull verbiage to weed through to get to them.


My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply