by - sam0282 on Thu May 31 2007 02:20:33
penn's portrayal seemed over the top almost all the time,
Sheesh, at that time, the overall behavior of the LAPD's "CRASH" unit was just as much over the top. There's more than enough documentation existing to demonstrate that Officer McGavin's antics (Penn) were NOT made up...
s was oand duvall just seemed to not care all that much.
Not true. Officer Hodges (Duvall) is carefully based on a real LAPD officer named Tony Moreno, who believed in a strategy of working with the gangs to get the bigger fish, opposed to CRASH's philosophy, which was to be another gang on the street. Moreno has a book out now, available at major retailers.
much of the movie seems unrealistic as far as proper police protocol.
Remember, the policing scenes depicted in this film were based on the CRASH unit, not the regular LAPD. The CRASH unit was wild. That's part of the reason they were disbanded. A lot of people believe they are at least partly responsible for the riots. They policed LA's poor neighborhoods like gestapos.
maybe that is how they did things in 1988 LA but it seems farfetched to me.
To be honest with you, it's just the opposite. It's more like a quick run down. The CRASH unit did some foul stuff to get their message out. This movie actually watered down their behavior a bit. Remember, Dennis Hopper, despite his hippy persona, has disclosed himself to be more of a conservative over the years. He actually made the cops out to be the good guys in this, actually making McGAvin, PAc Man himself, out to be the protagonist by movie's end.
understand there is meant to be a message but it gets lost through all the junk. i saw this movie on at 3 am and it got a good review so i gave it a chance... i regret that decision and the 2 hours i wasted. please tell me i am not the only one dissapointed by this so called "glimpse into LA gang life"
There are plenty of people who'd agree with you, I'm sure. But if they have the same problems with the film that you do, it's likely they, and you, could be misinformed or, with all due respect, in denial, of what the CRASH unit and LA's gangs were like in the '80s.
reply
share