ABT II - three hour version


anybody seen the three hour version or the 2hr and 40 minute version? when you are watching the movie, there are many jump cuts that shows parts of scene are missing. here's story behind it in cityonfire.com:

This film was originally over three hours in length and the studio balked at Woo for its length. The film was then cut down to two hours and forty minutes so John Woo & Tsui Hark (the producer) had to cut the film separately under a very limited period of time due to pressure from the studio and distributors to trim the film down to get more screenings in cinemas. Therefore, the film had suffered terribly causing Woo to disown it.

The problem is that Woo was given a very short time to edit the film and to make matters worse both Woo & producer Tsui Hark had clashed as to how the film should be made so with Tsui being the producer, he had equal control with the editing of this film along with three others (Woo being the fifth editor). Woo didn't even know who was editing what. Needless to say, the editing makes the film incoherent, incomprehensible, inconsistent, inane and insane (not to mention irresolute); which is really a shame as if it was left uncut, it could have been a classic.

At best, the recent/regular version is a cult classic but even in its hideously disfigured form, the film still has shades of bravado even if those shades are merely shadows of its former brilliant self.

The second time I saw this film, I compiled a list of scenes that were cut (i.e. scenes that looked like they were abridged...even frames of a single shot) and it's really obvious that a lot of scenes were cut.

it would have been awesome if the longer version exist.

reply

The theatrical trailer has quite a few deleted scenes/shots on display.

You can watch it here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOhyyUCBh-8

reply

Woov never heard of this one before

reply

This movie is tied with The Wicker Man for "movie I most want to see restored". With The Wicker Man there's not much chance of it happening unless there's a MIRACULOUS discovery in someone's archives, as numerous people involved with the film have tried very hard for over 30-something years, but is ABT2's cut footage necessarily lost? It probably is, given how insane its editing was, but if there's any sort of chance I wish someone like Tarantino or some other resourceful HK action fan would take up the mission to find the cut footage and get this one restored. Not sure if John Woo himself is interested (or maybe just too busy over the years to revisit this one), otherwise he probably would have tried. I wouldn't care if it was found on a crappy VHS like Event Horizon and the footage was cut back in from that.


WARNING: Some posts were written on my iPad. And some were dictated to Siri... >.>

reply