Longer Cut ?


I recently saw a documentary that said there was a longer french cut of this film and i was wondering if anyone knew anything ?

Think with Objectivity, and become depressed
Action is the enemy of thought

reply

Not familiar with the doc or the French cut but the Region 1 DVD is an Unrated Director's Cut 146 min., 1.33:1 aspect ratio (which it states on the packaging is the format in which it was filmed). I see on this site that there is a region 2 DVD with an aspect ratio of 2.35:1 (widescreen), so someone is wrong... I payed less than $5.00 for this DVD and it contains only the film and scene selections, no subtitles which would have been nice in some parts. You get what you pay for but the film is unique and worth watching...it is not The Godfather by any means but it is not as bad as its 4.9 rating on this site...

reply

Can you tell me where I can get this version as Amazon.com does not cerry this DVD?

reply

The European version was 146 minutes and was released both theatically and on DVD (in 2.35:1) outside the USA.


"Gentlemen, is this a great moment or a small one? I'm afraid I don't know."

reply

I've never seen the short version, only the original 146 mn cut, and I thought that it was a great movie. Not a masterpiece as The Godfather, obviously, but it's tremendously good nevertheless... And Christopher Lambert is perfectly credible as Giuliano.

reply

I'd love to see the director's cut. The letterbox version I have is 113 minutes long. Now I know why I didn't understand the plot. However, the film is very beautiful to watch nonetheless.

reply

The film is 140 min long, but it's so disjointed you just have to bear with it for an hour or so. It picks up from the half mark when the violence comes into play, but nothing ever saves the film. It literally plays as if someone cut every other scene out - OR - it had a bunch of effective scenes and setpieces jammed together without any visual linking material. It's got unappealing central characters - Lambert probably got the gig because the film had him lying on a table bleeding to death and riding a horse like in Highlander, he's not really bad, but he's wrong for his character. Terrence Stamp and Joss Ackland look distinguished and do very little. Barbara Sukowa is badly dubbed and I didn't quite get why was that character even there - she does her thing and disappears. John Turturro did okay, Michael Wincott was great. Pretty locale. But there's just nothing there, no natural emotion, instead a lot of sad music to force it. If it had more violence, it'd make more money I think, because that's among the things that work in the movie. A different cut might've been better.

reply

You summed it up about right, asgard. I like giving the film a spin once in a while to see if there is anything I can pick up communicated by Cimino, but it's hopeless. Stiil weirdly watchable for some reason.....

Please nest your IMDB page, and respond to the correct person -

reply



curtise-1
One thing I remember about the shorter/theatrical version is that it does not include the love scene with Camilla, Duchess of Crotone. When Giuliano and his gang invade her house party, steal her's and her guests' jewelry, they immediately leave -wanting and needing nothing more from this roomful of the priviledged elite. This theatrical version shows Giuliano more as a Robin Hood-type revolutionary with a disciplined determination to restore to the peasants some of Sicily's wealth that had been stolen from them. Giuliano was not tempted or distracted by the allure of the Duchess, and remained faithful to his crusade (and his fiancee, Giovanna). It was refreshing to see Giuliano show this spoiled, overindulged Duchess that there was something (and someone) in this world she could not have -just because she wanted it.
Instead, in the extended Director's Cut, we see the invasion of the house party, the robbery of the Duchess and her guests, then Giuliano's men waiting nervously and impatiently outside the bedroom (still holding the house guests at gunpoint) waiting for Giuliano to complete this sexual tryst, and meaningless diversion, with the Duchess.
I think restoring this scene from the cutting room floor detracted from the character of Giuliano as an idealistic revolutionary and reduced him to the level of a run-of-the-mill egomaniac.

reply

[deleted]

I saw this version, it was even in TV right here in Canada and like 3 hours with commercials, i could not tell you what is different since i only saw this version ! ;-)

Last Movies:- Sherlock Holmes - 4,5/5
- Book of Eli - 4/5
- Daybreakers - 3,5/5

reply

I have only scene the 146 version of the film. Found a DVD of it used at the store just last week.

"Inside everyone is a frontier waiting to be discovered"

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]